Mantex

Tutorials, Study Guides & More

  • HOME
  • REVIEWS
  • TUTORIALS
  • HOW-TO
  • CONTACT
>> Home / Archives for Edgar Allan Poe

Tales of Mystery and Imagination

April 29, 2011 by Roy Johnson

short stories of Gothic horror and the macabre

Tales of Mystery and Imagination is the name often given to collections of Poe’s stories. Edgar Allan Poe is celebrated as the originator of several types of short story – the tale of Gothic horror, the science fiction story, the detective story, the tall tale, the puzzle, and the literary hoax. In fact he was preceded in some of these by E.T.A. Hoffmann, but his influence has been much more widespread, and interestingly, given this influence, he was the first well-known American author to earn his living through writing – though this did not prevent him dying in poverty and neglect (dressed in somebody else’s clothes).

Tales of Mystery and ImaginationHe often starts a story with a philosophic reflection, and the central purpose of the story is to illustrate the idea. But what makes them so striking and memorable is that the idea is both articulated via the narrator’s anguished state of mind and encapsulated in a vivid image – going down in a sinking ship; suffering torture in the Spanish Inquisition; a premature burial; and a heart which continues to beat even after a brutal murder. These are images of the Gothic that have kept the horror movie industry fuelled with content for almost the last hundred years.

Very little is overtly dramatized in Poe stories. Characters rarely engage in conversation. Everything is in the grip of a narrator who is normally relating events at emotional fever pitch. “I was sick – sick unto death … why will you say I am mad … tomorrow I die, and to-day I would unburthen my soul.” These are the voices of existential anxiety we have come to know via Dostoyevski, Nietzsche, and Kafka.

In his stories lots of things happen twice. A man is stranded on a doomed ship, which is struck by another bigger vessel and takes him into the Abyss. A man has a beautiful wife who falls ill and dies. When he remarries, his second wife goes the same way. Another man has a wife who dies giving birth to a girl – who becomes a replica of her mother, and dies the same way. The women in his stories do not last long. Even if they start out as beautiful young maidens, they tend to become sickly, they fade, they die, and are entombed. In one of his most famous doppelganger stories, the protagonist William Wilson is pursued throughout his debauched life by another man who looks exactly the same, and is also called William Wilson. You don’t need a brass plaque on your front door to realise that these are stories of split personality, of guilty conscience, of the duality of being.

Poe is perhaps most celebrated as the inventor of the detective story. In The Murders in the Rue Morgue his super-intellectual hero Auguste Dupin solves an almost impossibly difficult problem (murder in a locked room) by what appears to be a combination of acute observation and pure reason. He is presented with the same eyewitness accounts as the police, but outsmarts them by superior logic. (Actually, Poe cheats slightly by having Dupin locate extra clues).

But Poe is less interested in dramatizing the solution to a crime than exploring the misconceptions that make things seem mysterious or puzzling in the first place’. Dupin spends most of his time explaining why the Prefect of the Parisian police cannot solve crimes because his thinking is trammelled in convention. Despite all the improbabilities of the plot (windows with hidden spring catches, an Ourang-Utang with a cutthroat razor) the tale established a formula for the detective story which has survived to this day.

In terms of the Gothic tradition, Poe piles one effect upon another – entombment, necrophilia, ruined abbeys, murder, alcohol and drugs. Nothing is spared in his quest to express intensity of emotion and horror of effect. In one of the other famous pieces in this collection, ‘The Fall of the House of Usher’, Poe combines themes of incest, premature burial, and a decaying mansion that ends up split asunder and collapsing into its own moat. All the stories cry out for interpretation, and it is to his credit that despite what are often seen as moments of dubious excess (rotting corpses, a protagonist who extracts all his wife’s teeth before she is dead) they continue to yeild up meaning to a succession of readings even today – more than one hundred and fifty years after they were first written.

Tales of Mystery and Imagination Buy the book at Amazon UK

Tales of Mystery and Imagination Buy the book at Amazon US

© Roy Johnson 2011


Edgar Allan Poe, Selected Tales, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008, pp.338, ISBN: 0199535779


More on literature
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: 19C Horror, Short Stories, The Short Story Tagged With: Edgar Allan Poe, Gothic horror, Literary studies, The Short Story

The Mystery of Marie Roget

May 1, 2017 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, commentary, study resources, and web links

The Mystery of Marie Roget (1842) is Edgar Allan Poe’s second story featuring his philosophic amateur detective the Chevalier C. Auguste Dupin. This intellectual super-sleuth made his first appearance the year before in The Murders in the Rue Morgue and appeared for the last time in Poe’s 1844 story, The Purloined Letter.

Marie Roget is based on a real-life crime that took place in New York City in 1841 when the corpse of a young girl called Mary Rogers was found floating in the Hudson River. The original murder was never really solved – which is perhaps why Poe leaves his story technically ‘unfinished’.

Edgar Allan Poe


The Mystery of Marie Roget – commentary

The story follows the formula Poe devised for The Murders in the Rue Morgue. An un-named narrator presents the hero-detective Dupin as a somewhat world-weary bohemian with an outstanding intellect. Dupin is then landed with the difficult problem of a crime which the police cannot solve.

The structure of the story then follows in essentially two parts – the presentation of the evidence, then the analysis of the facts.

  • Marie Roget disappears, then her corpse is found in the Seine – everyone is baffled by the problem
  • Dupin examines all the evidence related to the crime – then speculates on possible explanations

There is a missing third part to the story which makes itself quite noticeably felt. We do not know if Dupin’s interpretation of events is correct or not. He draws up a list of what might be the solution(s) to the mystery. His conclusion is that further investigations might confirm the veracity of his speculations, but we do not know if these theories are valid or not.

That is the major weakness of this story, and the reason why it is not so successful as its companion pieces, The Murders in the Rue Morgue and The Purloined Letter.

But in drawing up his explanations for what might have happened, Poe makes some interesting observations which throw light onto the secondary subject of the story, which is the character of Dupin himself. He has a fresh and original way of looking at the evidence:

the proper question in cases such as this, is not so much ‘what has occurred?’ as ‘what has occurred that has never occurred before?’

He also makes plain a scathing critique of the newspapers and superficial journalism which runs through all of the Dupin stories. Not only are the police incompetent in failing to solve the crimes, but the newspapers merely highlight sensational details – to increase their sales.

The irresponsible highlighting of these graphic details actually obscures the truth of what really happened in the crime and impedes its solution. This critique of press irresponsibility was made more than one hundred and fifty years ago – and may be regarded as still valid today..

We should bear in mind that, in general, it is the object of our newspapers rather to create a sensation — to make a point — than to further the cause of truth.

The main problem with this tale as a short story is that it lacks any sense of dramatic movement and it certainly doesn’t have any genuine resolution. There is no active pursuit of a criminal; all activity relating to the crime has already taken place before the story begins; and we do not know if Dupin’s suppositions are valid or not. As the critic Howard Haycraft observed, “The characters neither move nor speak”

These weaknesses arise from the very origins of the story. Poe wrote the tale when the mysterious crime was still fresh in the public’s mind. He also promoted the story as his own original solution to the mystery. It was even published in two parts. But the fact is that the crime had not been solved. Indeed it never has been solved. However, the story does have the distinction of being the first detective murder mystery to be based upon a real life crime.


The Mystery of Marie Roget – study resources

The Mystery of Marie Roget Poe: The Ultimate Collection – Amazon UK

The Mystery of Marie Roget Poe: The Ultimate Collection – Amazon US

The Mystery of Marie Roget  Poe: Collected Tales – Penguin – Amazon UK

The Mystery of Marie Roget Poe: Collected Tales – Penguin – Amazon US

The Mystery of Marie Roget Tales of Mystery and Imagination – Kindle illustrated – UK

The Mystery of Marie Roget Tales of Mystery and Imagination – Kindle illustrated – US


The Mystery of Marie Roget – story synopsis

Following Auguste Dupin’s success in solving the mysteries of the murders in the Rue Morgue, his fame spreads amongst the Parisian police. The attractive Marie Roget lives with her widowed mother who keeps a pension. Marie works in a perfume shop in Palais Royal owned by M Le Blanc

Marie suddenly disappears for a week, returns home, then disappears a second time, after which her corpse is found floating in the Seine. The Police are baffled. A reward is offered, then doubled a week later. After a month the chief of the Prefecture visits Dupin with a request for help – to save his reputation and honour.

The narrator then gathers depositions and newspaper reports of the crime. Her body was badly mutilated, she was interred, then exhumed for further investigation. Public outrage rose as time passed without results. It is suggested that the body might be that of somebody else.

An outsider M. Beauvais takes a close interest in identifying the body – although a friend of his identifies it sooner. The newspapers throw direct suspicion on M. Beauvais, but he protests his innocence.

Some boys find remnants of clothing in the woods and a handkerchief bearing the name ‘Marie Roget’. The landlady of a nearby tavern reports the appearance of a young man and woman. There are screams later. Then the dead body of Marie Roget’s fianc*eacute;e is found in the same spot, along with a suicide note

Dupin is severely critical of the newspapers and the police. He submits the text of one journalist’s report to close critical examination, and goes into a detailed account of the physics of bodies drowning in water. He is particularly scathing about journalistic generalisations, cliches, and sloppy reasoning.

Dupin thinks it is necessary to look outside the immediate events of the mystery. He digs up several news reports which at first seem unrelated to the mystery. He analyses the garments found at the crime scene and argues that they have been planted there. Then he compares the likelihood of a single murderer with that of a gang.

His analysis of the evidence points to the conclusion that the murderer must be the sailor with whom Marie Roget previously eloped. He suggests that further interviews should be conducted with this in mind. The narrator concludes with a comparison of the real historical crime of Mary Rogers, then further reflections on chance and possibility.

© Roy Johnson 2017


More on Edgar Allan Poe
More on literature
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Edgar Allan Poe Tagged With: Edgar Allan Poe, English literature, Literary studies, The Short Story

The Purloined Letter

July 22, 2017 by Roy Johnson

The Purloined Letter (1844) marks the third and final appearance of Edgar Allan Poe’s master-detective, the Parisian‘ gentleman’ Chevalier C. Auguste Dupin. He first appeared in The Murders in the Rue Morgue (1841) and then again in The Mystery of Marie Roget (1842). He is also quite clearly the original inspiration for Arthur Conan Doyle’s detective, Sherlock Holmes.

Edgar Allan Poe

The story first appeared in the Christmas literary annual The Gift published in Philadelphia in December 1845. Poe received a payment of only $12.00 for its first printing, but the story was reprinted in many newspapers and magazines in the years that followed.


The Purloined Letter – critical comment

The short story

Edgar Allen Poe’s short stories are generally collected under the title of Tales of Mystery and Imagination. In them, Poe explored a wide range of topics and themes. He is most famous for his tales of Gothic horror – such as The Black Cat, The Pit and the Pendulum, and Ligeia. But he also invented the detective story; he wrote tales of science fiction (The Balloon Hoax); spoofs and satires (The Man Who was Used Up); and puzzles or cryptograms such as The Gold Bug.

He wrote prolifically for newspapers and magazines. As a result of his engagement with the shorter literary forms he developed a theory of short stories which is still relevant today. He claimed that a successful short story should follow a set of rules.

  • It should be read at one sitting
  • It should create a ‘unity of effect’
  • It should contain nothing superfluous
  • It should strike its note in the first sentence
  • It should be imaginative and original

The Purloined Letter is successful because it meets all these requirements. The mystery is focussed on one topic – the missing letter. There are no digressions. All parts of the tale relate to its discovery, and the story begins and ends ‘on topic’ – with the loss of the letter and its discovery.

The story has a perfectly reasonable premise. A potentially compromising letter has been stolen and cannot be located by the police. The problems this raises are then explored, and the letter is located by Dupin. The story ends with an explanation of how he found it.

Its aesthetic superiority is evident when compared with the other two Dupin stories. The Murders in the Rue Morgue depends upon a rather improbable premise – an escaped Orang-Outang armed with a cut-throat razor. The Mystery of Marie Roget offers an exhaustive analysis of evidence for a puzzling murder, but it is technically unresolved. The Purloined Letter has neither of these weaknesses.

Structure

The success of this story is principally explained by its sound structure. The narrative is in three distinct parts:

  • the problem and how it came about
  • the efforts that were made to solve it
  • Dupin’s explanation of his strategic success

The story also has an interesting structural feature. The missing letter does not suddenly appear at the end of the story as a coup de theatre, thus providing a resolution to the tale. It is unexpectedly produced half way through the story, when Dupin raffishly claims the 50,000 Francs reward for its discovery. This is a mark of Poe’s genius as a story teller.

The essence of the story is not about the social value of the letter to its addressee (the Queen) or someone else who might read it (the King). There is a suggestion that the compromising contents of the letter will reveal the fact that the Queen has been sexually unfaithful to the King. But Poe’s principal interest is about how the letter is discovered.

The ‘twist’ in the tale is that the letter was in full view of the police all the time. It was not, as the police suspected, concealed in any secret drawer, in the stuffing of a chair seat, or behind the wallpaper of D—’s room. It was fully on view – but it had been disguised as a letter of no importance addressed to someone else.

The French connection

Poe’s literary reputation has always been high in France, and there has been a great deal of literary analysis of The Purloined Letter by modernist critics of the 1960s and 1970s. This debate is summarised in the story’s Wikipedia entry.

This debate mainly centres on the symbolic significance of the letter in relation to the Queen who has received it and her husband the King who apparently is being deceived. However, this discussion ignores the fact that Poe is quite clearly more interested in how Dupin discovers the letter than in the social ramifications of its contents – which are not known anyway.

These approaches to literary of analysis flow from the various schools of criticism which were fashionable in France around that time. These took a stance that literary texts could have more or less any meaning that could be read into them, irrespective of the author’s intention or even an intelligent reader’s understanding of ‘the story’.

The two best known of these theories – structuralism and deconstruction – were popular and influential in Europe and America until the end of the twentieth century. But in recent years they have fallen out of favour, largely because they are now considered elitist and woefully obscure. They also have the weakness that they frequently lack common sense.


The Purloined Letter – study resources

The Purloined Letter Poe: The Ultimate Collection – Amazon UK

The Purloined Letter Poe: The Ultimate Collection – Amazon US

The Purloined Letter Poe: Collected Tales – Penguin classics – Amazon UK

The Purloined Letter Poe: Collected Tales – Penguin classics – Amazon US

The Purloined Letter Tales of Mystery and Imagination – illustrated – Amazon UK

The Purloined Letter Tales of Mystery and Imagination – illustrated – Amazon US


A Bundle of Letters


The Purloined Letter – story synopsis

Auguste Dupin and the narrator are joined by G— the chief of the Prefecture of the Paris Police. He reports the theft of a compromising letter by the minister D— in full view of its royal recipient and her husband.

D— has not yet acted on the content of the letter but the police chief has failed in all his attempts to recover it. He has even taken apart the furniture in D—’s rooms and searched adjacent houses. Dupin advises him to look more carefully.

A month later G— returns, still unsuccessful. A reward for the recovery of the letter has been doubled to 50,000 Francs. Dupin asks for a cheque to that amount, and in exchange he hands over the letter.

When G-— has gone, Dupin explains to the narrator that G—’s methods are indeed very thorough, but they are limited because he fails to put himself into the mindset of his antagonist. Dupin criticises mathematical logic because it is a self-enclosed system which cannot be applied in the moral universe.

He then describes his visit to minister D— in his office where he spots the letter, distressed, torn, and disguised, in a letter rack on the mantelpiece. Dupin deliberately leaves a snuff box behind, and returns next day to collect it. Whilst D—’s attention is distracted he takes the letter and replaces it with a dummy copy he has made.

© Roy Johnson 2017


More on Edgar Allan Poe
More on literature
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Edgar Allan Poe Tagged With: Edgar Allan Poe, English literature, Literary studies, The Short Story

William Wilson

April 29, 2017 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, commentary, study resources, and web links

William Wilson was first published in the October 1839 issue of Burton Gentleman’s Magazine. Later in 1844 it was translated into French and published in the Paris newspaper La Quotidienne. This marked the first introduction of Poe’s work into France, where it has been highly regarded ever since.

The story has surprisingly autobiographical elements. During his youth Poe spent some time at Manor House School in Stoke Newington in north London, on which the ‘academy’ in the story is based. However, he did not go on to either Eton or Oxford University – which he describes in the tale as ‘the most dissolute university in Europe’.

Edgar Allan Poe


William Wilson – critical summary

The double

This is an early and now-famous example of the double in literature – sometimes known by its German term the ‘Doppelganger’. The elements of a double in the story should be quite clear from the start. William Wilson is confronted by another schoolboy at the academy who has the same name as himself. They have the same birthday; they are the same height; they wear the same clothes; and they both join the academy and leave it on exactly the same day.

Wilson is exasperated by the appearances of what he perceives as a ‘rival’, and yet the double gives him ‘advice’ which Wilson, writing in retrospect, now wishes he had heeded. It is also significant that nobody else in the story seems to be aware of the double; he ‘appears’ only to Wilson himself.

“Yet this superiority — even this equality — was in truth acknowledged by no one but myself; our associates, by some unaccountable blindness, seemed not even to suspect it.”

It is one of the common features of the double in literature that it appears only to the protagonist of the story or the novel. The double figure acts as ‘another self’ to the protagonist which acts as the embodiment of good, evil, or ‘otherness’. It is for this reason that stories featuring a double are often seen as studies in psychological aberration or what is often called ‘the divided self’.

It should be fairly clear that William Wilson’s double is a manifestation of his conscience. The double appears at crucial moments when Wilson is about to commit a morally dubious act. Because the story is narrated from Wilson’s point of view, there is a strong tendency for the reader to be sympathetic to the account of events he gives us. He sees the double as a source of irritation and interference. But the double, the conscience, is merely giving him advice, and warnings – always in a low tone of voice.

The epitaph to this story provides an unmistakable clue to Poe’s intended meaning.

What say of it? what say Conscience grim,
That spectre in my path?

The essential conflict is between Wilson who wishes to do wrong, and his conscience which is warning him against himself. The two finally clash at the Roman ball, where Wilson finally kills off his double, only to discover that he is killing himself. The double tells him – no longer in a whisper – “In me didst thou exist—and in my death, see … how utterly thou hast murdered thyself.”

The Double An extended tutorial on The Double

Structure

William Wilson follows all of Poe’s own rules for the constituents of a successful short story. It strikes its distinctive tone from the opening sentence – ‘Let me call myself, for the present, William Wilson’. And the story deals with that one topic alone – the inner identity (and conflict) of the protagonist.

Poe also claimed that a story should have a ‘unity of effect’. That is, all the elements of the story should be directed towards the point it is trying to make. This means in its turn that there should not be any digressions or the inclusion of unrelated material. William Wilson certainly does follow this rule. The story begins with Wilson’s anguish over his personal identity, and the focus of attention remains on that topic until the story’s dramatic finale.

Oscar Wilde

The striking image of ‘self’ destruction at the conclusion of the story was echoed famously by Oscar Wilde in the conclusion to his novel The Picture of Dorian Gray.

Wilde’s is another story of moral decline, in which the protagonist becomes progressively degenerate yet remains amazingly youthful in appearance. He finally confronts a portrait painting of himself which has aged in an attic to reveal his corruption. In a rage he stabs the painting with a knife and is found dead with the knife in his own heart – and the portrait has become young once again.

The idea of a portrait hidden in an attic which reveals the unpleasant truth about someone’s behaviour and age has become a commonplace image and figure of speech – often humorously applied. It is rightly attributed to Wilde, but it has its origins in Edgar Allan Poe.


William Wilson – study resources

William Wilson Poe: The Ultimate Collection – Amazon UK

William Wilson Poe: The Ultimate Collection – Amazon US

William Wilson Poe: Collected Tales – Penguin – Amazon UK

William Wilson Poe: Collected Tales – Penguin – Amazon US

William Wilson Tales of Mystery and Imagination – Kindle illustrated – UK

William Wilson Tales of Mystery and Imagination – Kindle illustrated – US

William Wilson William Wilson at Wikipedia


William Wilson – plot summary

William Wilson’s reputation has been ruined, and as death approaches him he wishes to make a record of his descent into wickedness.

Believing that he has inherited a ‘remarkable’ nature, he recalls his youth as a schoolboy in England. His academy school is like a Gothic prison, and its ethos is disciplinarian. Another boy with the same name becomes a competitor and a rival.

Wilson is worried by the other boy’s easy superiority, but it is not noticed by anybody else. The two boys have the same birthday, they are the same height, and they join the school on the same day.

They become inseparable companions. The rival can only speak in a very low voice, but he dresses in the same clothes as Wilson. He also takes pleasure in his superiority – though this is noticed only by Wilson himself.

The rival patronises Wilson and gives him advice, which Wilson now wishes he had heeded. Wilson visits the rival’s bedroom at night whilst he is asleep – but he does not look the same.

Wilson leaves the academy and goes to Eton where he plunges himself into a life of folly and vice. One drunken night he is visited by the rival who raises a warning finger then disappears.

Wilson moves on to Oxford University where he uses his wealth to gamble and take advantage of others. On the occasion of completely ruining a young nobleman he is visited again by the rival, who reveals to the company that Wilson has been cheating at cards. Next morning he leaves the university in disgrace and flees to the Continent.

The double figure pursues him throughout Europe, thwarting his plans for ‘bitter mischief’. Finally at a masked ball in Rome, the figure appears when Wilson is about to seduce a young married woman. Wilson draws a rapier to kill the figure, but finds himself confronting his own image in a full length mirror, spattered with blood, and saying ‘thou hast murdered thyself’.

© Roy Johnson 2017


More on Edgar Allan Poe
More on literature
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Edgar Allan Poe Tagged With: Edgar Allan Poe, English literature, Literary studies, The Short Story

Get in touch

info@mantex.co.uk

Content © Mantex 2016
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Clients
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Links
  • Services
  • Reviews
  • Sitemap
  • T & C’s
  • Testimonials
  • Privacy

Copyright © 2025 · Mantex

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in