Mantex

Tutorials, Study Guides & More

  • HOME
  • REVIEWS
  • TUTORIALS
  • HOW-TO
  • CONTACT
>> Home / Archives for Evelyn Waugh

A Handful of Dust

February 23, 2018 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, study guide, commentary, and further reading

A Handful of Dust (1934) was Evelyn Waugh’s fourth novel. It was very well received on first publication, and he followed it up with similar acerbic satires such as Scoop (1938) and Put Out More Flags (1942). After the war his novels became more serious. Brideshead Revisited (1945) and the Sword of Honour trilogy (1952-1961) explore similar themes in a more sober fashion, though there are still brilliant flashes of humour in all his work.

A Handful of Dust


A Handful of Dust – critical commentary

Social decline

Evelyn Waugh’s essential subject matter is the study of upper-class decline and its causes. He is powerfully attracted to a nostalgic view of traditional aristocratic life in grand country houses and estates, together with all their culture of inherited wealth and property. This includes the architecture of previous centuries, and the social life of weekend parties, plentiful servants, and an existence divided between London and a house in the country.

But he knew it was a social system that was coming to an end. It was a privileged economy which could not be sustained. And he knew that the principal characters caught up in this decline were conspiring in their own downfall – by over-indulgence, wilful excess, and moral blindness to the changing world in which they lived.

The middle class characters in his novels are largely endeavouring to claw their way into this decadent echelon, and their tastes and habits are generally presented as inferior, awkward, and doomed to failure. The lower orders hardly feature at all, except as occasional servants. Waugh does not have a simplistic hope that any working class people are going to be the saviours of this decline.

Humour

Waugh’s early novels were once regarded as the last thing in barbed humour and rib-tickling satire. They don’t seem quite so humorously pointed now, but there remain traces of comic characterisation, and he does have the distinction of introducing an element of black comedy into the modern novel.

Mrs Beaver’s greed and relentless opportunism are funny because they are linked to the main theme of downward social mobility. She has come from the upper echelons of society but has fallen on hard times as a widow with a socially useless son. She lives in Sussex Gardens – then a downmarket region of Bayswater- but she misses no opportunity to sell people what we would now call fashionable junk or tat from her shop

She has also devised the entrepreneurial scheme of splitting up houses into smaller flats to rent. Her clients are people who have dubious purposes, as does Brenda, and those who are downwardly socially mobile such as ‘Princess’ Jenny Abdul Akbar. Mrs Beaver simultaneously promotes her services to these people as a so-called interior designer.

She also embodies all that Waugh finds offensive in modernism and a lack of sensitivity to tradition. In the middle of the novel she is converting one of the rooms in Tony Last’s old Tudor home Hetton Abbey by lining the walls with chromium plate.

It is interesting that Waugh sees the issue of social decline in architectural terms – from the draughty grandeur of Hetton Abbey to these ‘service flats’ carved out of the Victorian splendour of London’s Belgravia.

Another marvellously comic character is Mr Tendril the local preacher at Hetton. He is a hopelessly indurate creation who goes on preaching sermons he has written years before for troops in British expeditionary wars in India. His speeches contain references to the pitiless sun, threats from tigers, and loved ones back at home – when he is addressing a congregation in what seems to be rural Warwickshire.

How difficult it is for us to realise that this is indeed Chhristmas. Instead of the glowing log fire and widows tight shuttered against the drifting snow, we have only the harsh glare of an alien sun; instead of the happy circle of loved faces, of home and family, we have the uncomprehending stares of the subjugated, though no doubt grateful, heathen. Instead of the placid ox and ass of Bethlehem, we have for companions the ravening tiger and the exotic camel, the furtive jackal and the ponderous elephant.

And of course the most memorable scene in this novel is the black comedy of Mr Todd forcing Tony to read the works of Charles Dickens. The mad settler Todd cannot read himself, but enjoys their entertainment value, and uses that as an excuse to keep Tony prisoner.

The two endings

There is interpretive difficulty and even a possible dilemma concerning the end to A Handful of Dust. This is not surprising, because Waugh wrote the most reprinted version of the conclusion before he wrote the novel. On a visit to South America in 1933, whilst he was stranded in Boa Vista (‘Good View’) in northern Brazil, Waugh spent his time writing a story called The Man Who Liked Dickens, based on an eccentric character he had met. The story was published in Hearst’s International in the United States and reprinted in Nash’s Pall Mall Magazine in the UK.

It was ten months later before he began work on what was to become A Handful of Dust – and he did not have any clear plan for how it was to end. This problem of two endings was created because the novel was issued as a serial in America as well as a stand-alone one-volume publication in England. His story The Man Who Liked Dickens had already been published in America, so Waugh produced the alternative ending for serial publication.

The two endings are completely different, and they also create quite different meanings for the novel as a whole. Tony’s imprisonment by the quasi-madman Mr Todd is the more dramatic, and the more frequently reprinted. It continues the theme of downward social mobility that Waugh had explored earlier in Decline and Fall (1928) and it takes it to a new extreme.

Tony is the upholder of traditional aristocratic values and he cherishes the house and the country estate he has inherited. But he is betrayed by his adulterous wife, and when he seeks solace in foreign travel, he encounters only misery, discomfort, and finally a sort of living death. Mr Todd’s final thwarting of Tony’s hopes for rescue is truly black humour at its most grim. Tony’s relatives inherit Hetton Abbey, his wife marries one of his friends, and his existence is reduced to a memorial plaque in the chapel.

The problem with this ending is that there is an abrupt shift in tone, mise en scene, subject matter, and geographic location between the first three-quarters of the novel and its conclusion. The principal events and characters have been established at Hetton Abbey and in fashionable London. The sudden switch to an equatorial jungle and deranged explorers such as Doctor Messinger and Mr Todd is too much. It disrupts the coherence of the narrative. Waugh’s friend the novelist Henry Yorke wrote to him: “the end is so fantastic that it throws the rest out of proportion”.

The serial version of the ending is far more logical and coherent – but it is much shorter, not so dramatic, and it is not funny. In the alternative ending Tony merely returns from what has been a therapeutic cruise, and he ruefully drifts into a reconciliation with Brenda. It is a downbeat, not a catastrophic ending to events.

The setting, the characters, and the subject matter remain the same, as does the tone of the narrative. But there are important ramifications to this version of the novel’s conclusion. Tony returns to his estate as its living inheritor. He has also commissioned renovations to Hetton Abbey during his absence on the Caribbean cruise – and these works reverse the absurd ‘improvements’ Brenda has made at the suggestion of Mrs Beaver (the chromium-plated walls). Moreover, Tony secretly retains ownership of the flat in Belgravia, and he lies to Brenda about having got rid of it.

This alternative ending leaves Tony a little bruised, but intact. He has lost nothing – except his son – and Brenda is pregnant again. Hetton Abbey will have its new bathrooms, and he obviously has plans for a little ‘private life’ in the Belgravia flat. This is altogether a different ending – which in turn creates a different novel. It forces the reader to regard the preceding events in a more light-hearted manner. What was previously a downhill plunge into disaster and destruction suddenly becomes no more than a series of minor comic setbacks from which the protagonist emerges unscathed.


A Handful of Dust – study resources

A Handful of Dust – Penguin – Amazon UK

A Handful of Dust – Penguin – Amazon US

A Handful of Dust – Study Guide – Paperback – Amazon UK

A Handful of Dust – DVD film – Amazon UK

Evelyn Waugh: A Life Revisited – Amazon UK

A Handful of Dust

Evelyn Waugh – by Henry Lamb


A Handful of Dust – plot summary

Chapter One — John Beaver lives with his mother in the unfashionable district of Bayswater in reduced circumstances. She has an antiques shop: he is twenty-five, unpopular, and has no occupation.

Chapter Two — Tony Last and his wife Brenda live at Hetton Abbey – a cold Gothic country house. John Beaver arrives for the weekend as their largely uninvited guest. Everyone feels uncomfortable, but Brenda tries to be hospitable to Beaver.

Brenda thinks to have a pied-a-terre for her trips into London, and Mrs Beaver can supply rooms in Belgravia. John Beaver takes Brenda to dinner and they make the opening moves of a flirtation.

Their relationship develops into an adulterous affair, and it becomes the subject of social gossip in London, even though people wonder what she sees in him. Brenda moves into the flat then announces to her husband that she is going to take up some sort of study courses.

Chapter Three — Tony and Jock Grant-Menzies get drunk at their club and threaten to call on Brenda, who is at the flat with Beaver. They go to a nightclub instead. Brenda stays at the flat during the week and only goes home at weekends. She hopes to distract her husband with her pushy neighbour ‘Princess’ Jenny Abdul Akbar, but Tony does not like her. Jock brings to Hetton his ‘shameless blonde’ friend Mrs Rattery, who arrives by aeroplane.

There is a hunt meeting at which young John Last is killed by a frightened horse. Brenda is brought back from London, but she feels it is all over for her with Tony, and she asks him for a divorce.

Chapter Four — Tony arranges to take a prostitute from the nightclub to Brighton for the weekend to provide evidence for a divorce. Milly the prostitute insists on bringing her awkward young daughter along. Brenda’s family reveal that Beaver will not marry her unless she receives a large settlement as alimony. This means Tony would be forced to sell his house, so instead he refuses to proceed with the divorce.

Chapter Five — Tony embarks on an expedition to South America with the very dubious Doctor Messinger in search of a ‘lost city’. En route via the West Indies he has a brief on-board flirtation with an eighteen year old girl. When he reaches the jungle he is tormented by insect bites and thinks wistfully of home. Native bearers desert the expedition, so Tony and Messinger are stranded. Messinger is clearly lost and incompetent. Tony catches a fever and becomes delirious. Messinger goes to seek help, but he drowns in river rapids.

Meanwhile back in London John Beaver and Brenda cannot move on because there has been no divorce. His mother, sensing that the marriage might not happen, plans to take him to America. Brenda tries to get money from the family solicitor, but Tony has tied up their finances to restore Hetton – and he has made a new will.

Chapter Six — Tony is rescued and cured by an eccentric settler Mr Todd, who forces him to read aloud the works of Charles Dickens. As the months go by Todd thwarts Tony’s attempts to leave the jungle. A previous prisoner tried to escape, but died at the encampment. When a passing traveller calls, Tony secretly gives him a note begging for help. But some time later, when Tony is unconscious for two days from the effects of a local drink, rescuers arrive from Europe. Mr Todd gives them Tony’s watch, shows them a cross on a grave, and sends them away.

Chapter Seven — Hetton is inherited and taken over by Tony’s cousin Richard Last and his family. Brenda marries Jock Grant-Menzies. A commemorative plaque is unveiled in the Hetton chapel to record Tony’s death as an ‘explorer’.

The alternative ending — Tony returns from a sea cruise in the West Indies and is met by Brenda, who has been ditched by John Beaver. They re-unite faux de mieux, Tony returns to Hetton Abbey, and he secretly takes over Brenda’s flat in Belgravia.


A Handful of Dust – principal characters
Mrs Beaver an aggressively commercial antique shop owner
John Beaver her lacklustre and talentless son
Tony Last the owner of Hetton Abbey and estate
Brenda Last Tony’s adulterous wife
John Andrew Last their young son
Marjorie Brenda’s sister
Jock Grant-Menzies Tony’s friend
‘Princess’ Jenny Abdul Akbar Brenda’s next door neighbour in Belgravia
Mrs Rafferty the ‘shameless blonde’, an aviatrix
The Revered Tendril the eccentric vicar attached to Hetton
Mr Todd a mad explorer and settler
Doctor Messinger an incompetent explorer

© Roy Johnson 2018


More on Evelyn Waugh
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Evelyn Waugh Tagged With: A Handful of Dust, English literature, Evelyn Waugh, Literary studies, The novel

Black Mischief

April 25, 2018 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, commentary, study resources, web links

Black Mischief (1932) is Evelyn Waugh’s follow-up to Decline and Fall (1928) and Vile Bodies (1930). It is another sharply satirical novel which features his sceptical view of society between the two world wars. The setting is a fictional African country (Azania), but the main target of his satire is the English upper and ruling class. The novel also introduces the unscrupulous playboy character Basil Seal, who was due to re-appear in some of Waugh’s later work, particularly Put Out More Flags< (1942).

Black Mischief


Black Mischief – commentary

Characters

A great deal of the satire and comic drama of the novel is generated via the characters and their absurdly inappropriate attitudes to the situation in which they find themselves. These characters might have become stock figures in the time that has elapsed since they first appeared in 1932, but they are nonetheless funny and in some cases the hapless victims of black comedy.

The Emperor Seth is a typical example, and might also be considered something of a prophetic figure, given the number of African state rulers who have been educated in the public [that is, private] schools and the universities of Europe. He is a graduate of Oxford, from which he has emerged with a naive desire to import modern ideas and culture into a population that is still living in mud huts and that believes in witchcraft.

His proposals to promote birth control are embraced rapturously by the inhabitants of Azania – but only because they completely misunderstand the message. The official propaganda promotes the advantages of small families, but the natives cling to their traditions of unrestrained fertility. Seth prints new banknotes carrying his image – which are worthless – and he plans to introduce compulsory Esperanto as the lingua franca of his country.

Sir Samson Courteney (the ‘Envoy Extraordinary’) is a wonderful example of everything a English diplomatic panjandrum should not be. He is criminally idle, evades all responsibilities, and at the height of a civil war in the country is reluctant to attend to business because he is playing with a child’s rubber toy in his bath.

His wife is terminally naive: amidst war, bloodshed, and public hangings she is only concerned with planting flowers in the legation gardens. Their daughter Prudence is virtually a simpleton who ‘practises’ romance with the attache William Bland, and then becomes the helpless plaything of Basil Seal. When on return to England her plane is forced into a crash landing, she ends up as the main ingredient in a cannibal’s celebration cooking pot.

Basil Seal is an enduringly wonderful creation, a scabrous rogue, and a quite complex character. He has been successful academically at Oxford, but has squandered his inheritance. He is master of several languages, but he is unscrupulous to a degree. He scrounges money from his married lover, steals from his mother, and following his African adventures goes back unchanged to the trivialities of his life in upper-class London. His story is taken up in more detail in the later novel Put Out More Flags (1942).


Black Mischief – study resources

Black Mischief – Penguin – Amazon UK

Black Mischief – Penguin – Amazon US

Evelyn Waugh: A Life Revisited – Amazon UK

Evelyn Waugh: Six Novels – Amazon UK

Black Mischief

Evelyn Waugh – by Henry Lamb


Black Mischief – plot summary

Ch. One Debra Dowa is the capital city of Azania, an imaginary country in Africa. When the founder dies, rule passes to his grandson Seth, who has studied at Oxford University and is keen to adopt modern European culture into a country that is clearly not ready to accept it.

There is a civil war and people are fleeing the country. Cheating, corruption, and lying are rife, and executions by hanging are everyday events. But the victorious army is loyal to Seth, who is mainly concerned with the arrangements for his coronation.

Ch. Two Members of the British Legation concern themselves with trivia, complain about shortages, and are completely out of touch with their surroundings. There is absurd rivalry between foreign embassies.

Ch. Three Basil Seal has given up his position as an English member of parliament and thinks to go out to Azania, but he has no money, having squandered his inheritance. He cadges money from his lover and steals an emerald bracelet from his mother.

Ch. Four Basil arrives in Azania on the day of Seth’s inauguration, which is a shambles. The French legation regard him as a spy. There is a grand ball, fuelled by ‘Champagne’ supplied by the corrupt Armenian trader Youkoumian that he has made the same day.

Ch. Five Basil is appointed Minister of Modernisation with Youkoumian as financial secretary, who imports boots nobody needs. Basil and Youkoumian appoint themselves on to government concessions. A dispute arises with General Connolly over the supply of boots to troops. The boots are eventually issued, but the troops eat them.

Meanwhile Seth pronounces totalitarian edicts on birth control and compulsory physical exercise. Basil is having an affair with Prudence the British ambassador’s daughter. Youkoumian is a profiteer on all the ‘improvements’. The campaign to promote birth control is completely misunderstood by the natives. Seth prints new currency to enrich himself.

Ch. Six The animal rights campaigner Dame Mildred Porch arrives en route to England. The legation are ‘too busy’ to deal with her. Meanwhile Prince Achon the rightful heir to the throne is rescued from imprisonment in a monastery. Europeans leave the town, fearing trouble. Dame Mildred and her companion Miss Tan witness the birth control parade and a riot from the roof of their hotel. The oppositionists seize control.

Ch. Seven The English residents and travellers shelter at the legation, which irritates Sir Courtney. Prince Achon is crowned the new emperor, but dies during the ceremony. Basil arrives with camels, disguised as a native trader.

Planes arrive from Aden to rescue the English residents. The plane carrying Prudence is forced to crash land. Basil traces Seth, only to find that he has been killed by rival Boaz, who is himself killed by his own troops. Basil delivers a funeral oration for Seth, after which there is a ceremonial feast. It transpires that they have eaten Prudence.

Ch. Eight Basil returns to London where his friends have lost money after the UK has come off the gold standard. They do not want to hear his traveller’s tales. Azania becomes an Anglo-French protectorate and is administered by a new set of incompetents.


Black Mischief – main characters
Emperor Seth Oxford-educated chieftain
Krikor Youkoumian Armenian store owner and racketeer
General Connolly Irish head of Seth’s army
Black Bitch his common law native wife, later ‘Duchess of Ukaka’
Sir Samson Courteney British envoy to Azania
Prudence Courteney his simple and romantic daughter
William Bland honorary attache
Basil Seal amoral ex-Oxford adventurer and playboy
Mrs Angela Lyne Basil’s lover
Dame Mildred Porch animal rights campaigner
Lady Margot Metroland a rich and glamorous society woman

© Roy Johnson 2018


More on Evelyn Waugh
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Evelyn Waugh Tagged With: English literature, Evelyn Waugh, Literary studies, The novel

Brideshead Revisited

February 10, 2018 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, study guide, commentary, web links

Brideshead Revisited (1945) was the ninth novel written by Evelyn Waugh. He had established his literary reputation with a series of comic satires in the inter-war years including Decline and Fall (1928), A Handful of Dust (1934), and Scoop (1938). But Brideshead is altogether a more serious work, with only a couple of amusing interludes punctuating a study of aristocratic decline in the 1920s and 1930s. It was written during the Second World War, and along with Waugh’s later trilogy Sword of Honour (1952-1961) represents some of the most successful English fiction of that period.

Brideshead Revisited


Brideshead Revisited – commentary

The framed narrative – I

A framed narrative is one story enclosed within another. The term is used typically when the principal story is preceded or given its context by some sort of introduction. The ‘outer’ story might set the scene or supply the provenance for the ‘inner’ narrative. Then, when the principal story has been related, there may – or may not – be a return to the scene of the first. The outer elements ‘frame’ the main substance of the narrative. (For more on the framed narrative see below.)

Brideshead provides an excellent example of this framing technique. The novel opens towards the end of the Second World War when Charles Ryder’s infantry unit is stationed at Brideshead Castle. The mood and the atmosphere of this Prologue are austere and grim, with an emphasis on wartime food rationing and physical discomfort. But when the protagonist Ryder reaches the country estate and its ancestral house, he recognises it as the background to his earlier life during the previous twenty years.

His recollection of those years form the principal events of the novel – and they are in marked contrast to the prologue. Ryder meets Sebastian Flyte at Oxford University and is introduced to the extravagantly rich and somewhat decadent lifestyle of the English aristocracy. The events of the following years unfold in a privileged, indulgent, and cultivated milieu.

But then in the Epilogue the narrative frame is closed by a return to Ryder’s military existence in the 1940s. The beautiful ancestral home of the Flyte family at Brideshead is being vandalised by the billeted troops. The closing frame of the narrative matches that of the opening , and emphasises the contrast between the cultural values of the old and the new regime.

The first person narrative

Evelyn Waugh handles the delivery of the novel via first person narrative very skilfully. This mode is required to perform two important functions simultaneously– to reveal the character of the principal character, Charles Ryder, and to relate the series of events in which he becomes involved.

Charles is a sensitive and honourable chap who for the most part of the novel is operating outside his social depth. He comes from a lower social stratum than the people he befriends. It becomes immediately obvious to the reader that he is in danger of being led astray by his friendship with the recklessly indulgent Sebastian.

Fortunately, Sebastian is honourable too, even though he is on a self-destructive trajectory. But Charles does not fare so well with Sebastian’s sister Julia. Despite his attraction to her (which is signalled in the early part of the novel) it is obvious to the reader that she is essentially manipulative and cold-hearted, and in the end she rejects Charles in favour of her religious scruples.

Waugh also uses the device of narrative ellipsis: the reporting of important events are missed out of the story in order to create dramatic tension. For instance, Charles recounts his success as an architectural painter and his trip to Latin-America without at first revealing to the reader that he is married. It gradually emerges that he has discovered his wife’s infidelity – and thus has convincing reasons for not foregrounding the information.

He refers to at least one of their offspring as her child, which suggests that he suspects he might not be the father. All the subsequent exchanges between them reveal that Celia has been a cold and manipulative wife – just as Julia will ultimately be as a lover.

The main theme

There are two main themes in the novel – but they are closely linked. The more important theme is the decline of the English aristocracy, and the secondary theme is Charles Ryder’s attraction to all that its culture implies. As Evelyn Waugh remarked of his own design: “When I wrote Brideshead Revisited I was consciously writing an obituary of the doomed English upper class.”

The country estate of Brideshead Castle is the seat of the Flyte family and its head Lord Marchmain. The castle is gorgeously appointed and serviced by a large retinue of servants. But the titular head has decamped from the family home and is living with his mistress at a separate establishment in Venice. He is unable to regularise this situation socially because his wife refuses to give him a divorce, since she is a Catholic (a secondary or even tertiary theme).

But it gradually emerges that Lord Marchmain is running up debts because of this extravagant life style. And his offspring show every sign of accelerating the family’s decline. The family’s eldest son, emotionally constipated Bridey, eventually marries the middle-aged widow of a fellow matchbox collector. The daughter Julia marries arriviste Mottram, who cannot be formally recognised by the family because he is a divorcee. Even when Julia forms a relationship with the unhappy Charles Ryder, she cannot marry him because of a sudden resurgence of her Catholic beliefs.

The two younger members of the family are similarly blighted. Sebastian becomes a hopeless dipsomaniac and ends up destitute, attaching himself to a monastery in Tunisia. His younger sister Cordelia is entirely given up to nun-like behaviour and the pursuit of charitable works in war zones.

Yet Charles Ryder is clearly attracted to the world this family represents. He comes from a lower echelon of society. His father is rich enough to send him to Oxford and give him an allowance, but he limits this support – in a very amusing manner. Charles clings to Sebastian’s coat tails and accepts his generous hospitality and support.

He also falls in love with Sebastian’s sister, with whose good looks hers are frequently compared. There is another tertiary theme to the novel in the quasi-homosexual relationship between the two young men. And Ryder does eventually live at Brideshead with Julia (who inherits the house from her father). But he is denied his ambition to merge with the family because Julia is shocked by her father’s death into a resumption of her Catholic beliefs. Ryder’s outcome is to become “homeless, childless, middle-aged and loveless”.

It is no accident that this nostalgic yearning for an aristocratic heritage (even whilst recognising its decadence) has been the principal mood of two very glamorous and successful film adaptations of the novel. There was an eleven part television series in 1981produced by Granada Television, and an independent feature film in 2008 – both of which put enormous emphasis on this aspect of the narrative.

The novel also seems to have spawned any number of further aristocratic country house television dramas of the Upstairs, Downstairs variety. These depict late Victorian and early Edwardian upper-class life in a manner which simultaneously offers a sympathetic view of toffs with patronising sketches of life ‘below stairs’.

But the main purpose of these television and film dramas is to present comforting images of luxury, wealth, and cultivated living which offer a reassuring depiction of an earlier age to the viewer. Evelyn Waugh is partly responsible for dressing Brideshead Revisited in this nostalgic and escapist presentation of life.

But his view is also modified by having the glamour of Brideshead and transatlantic voyages sandwiched between grim scenes of Britain at war in the 1940s. He hopes the social vandals will not prevail, but he is not sure, and that doubt ultimately gives the novel its cutting edge.

The framed narrative – II

A typical and famous example of the framed narrative is Joseph Conrad’s Heart of Darkness (1902). His novella begins with an after-dinner conversation between sailors on the Thames. One of the characters (Marlow) relates his experiences sailing up river in the Belgian Congo. When he has finished, the story returns to the group still moored on the Thames. The main story is framed both by the geographic location and the philosophic reflections Marlow offers on historical comparisons between Europe and Africa.

Another famous example demonstrates the incomplete or one-sided frame. Henry James’ novella The Turn of the Screw (1898) opens with a similar group of people swapping stories after dinner. One of the party relates a horrifying tale which reveals the experiences of a governess looking after two children in an old house that appears to be haunted. But when the fears of the governess reach their dramatic climax, the novella ends, without returning to the opening scene.


Brideshead Revisited – study resources

Brideshead Revisited – Penguin – Amazon UK

Brideshead Revisited – Penguin – Amazon US

Brideshead – Study Guide – Paperback – Amazon UK

Evelyn Waugh: A Life Revisited – Paperback – Amazon UK

Brideshead Revisited – DVD – Amazon UK
The full 1980 Granada television series in 11-parts

Brideshead Revisited – DVD – Amazon UK
The 2008 BBC feature film version.

Brideshead Revisited

Evelyn Waugh – by Henry Lamb


Brideshead Revisited – plot summary

Prologue

During the latter years of the Second World War, Captain Charles Rider and his infantry army unit arrive at their temporary headquarters in the requisitioned country house of Lord Marchmain at Brideshead Castle.

Book One

Ch 1 Ryder recalls his early days at Oxford University twenty years previously and his meeting Sebastian Flyte, who takes him to his family’s stately home at Brideshead.

Ch 2 Charles is reproached by his cousin Jasper for mixing with the ‘wrong set’. Then aesthete Anthony Blanche reveals a critical account of Lord and Lady Marchmain’s troubled marriage.

Ch 3 Ryder returns home for the long vacation. He is in debt, but his father ignores his requests for help, and makes his life a misery behind a facade of loving concern. Sebastian tricks Charles into returning to Brideshead, where he meets his sister Julia Flyte.

Ch 4 Charles spends an idyllic summer at Brideshead with Sebastian. They visit Lord Marchmain in Venice, where Marchmain’s mistress Cara gives Charles a vivid account of the Lord’s hatred of his wife, who refuses to divorce him.

Ch 5 During a subdued second year at Oxford, Charles meets Rex Mottram. There is an excursion to a party in London where Charles, Sebastian, and Boy Mulcaster get drunk and spend time in jail. Christmas at Brideshead finds the Oxford don Samgrass being pious and boring. Sebastian feels oppressed by his family and starts drinking heavily. Lady Marchmain puts emotional pressure on Charles, and Sebastian is eventually sent down for a term. Charles decides to quit Oxford and take up painting.

Book Two

Ch 1 As a punishment, Sebastian is sent on a tour of Levantine monasteries with Samgrass, and on return to Brideshead is forbidden drink. He reveals to Charles that whilst on holiday he gave Samgrass the slip and is still drinking.

Charles is reproached by Lady Marchmain and he leaves Brideshead. He sets up as a painter in Paris, where he is visited by Rex Mottram, who reveals that the Flyte family are losing money through profligate over-indulgence. Mottram marries Julia later in the year in a very quiet wedding.

Ch 2 Charles recalls Julia’s ambitions to marry and its arriviste connotations. She becomes secretly engaged to Rex Mottram only because she is jealous of his affair with a married woman. Rex tries (unsuccessfully) to become a Catholic. It is then revealed that he is divorced after a former youthful marriage in Canada. The family object, and the marriage is low key and disastrous for everyone..

Ch 3 Charles returns from Paris to join National Service during the General Strike of 1926. Lady Marchmain dispatches Charles to bring back Sebastian from Morocco, where he finds him in hospital. Lady Marchmain dies. Charles makes paintings of the Flyte’s house in London, which is being sold off to developers to pay Lord Marchmain’s debts.

Book Three

Ch 1 Charles eventually becomes a successful architectural painter. He travels alone in Mexico and Central America for nearly two years, then joins his wife Celia in New York. Sailing back to England they meet Julia Flyte with whom Charles is in love. There is desultory socialising on board and a heavy storm. Charles and Julia exchange accounts of their failed marriages, sleep together, and arrange to meet in London.

Ch 2 Charles has an exhibition in London, and he evades going home. Anthony Blanche reappears, reports that Charles’ affair with Julia is public knowledge, and criticises his paintings. Charles and Julia travel to Brideshead, where her husband Rex is living.

Ch 3 Two years later Charles and Julia are living at Brideshead. Bridey announces that he is going to be married but cannot present his fiancee because Charles and Julia are ‘living in sin’. He plans to move his new family into the house, with his father’s consent.

Ch 4 Divorce proceedings are set in motion by Charles and Celia, then Rex and Julia. Cordelia returns from nursing the wounded in the Spanish Civil War with news of Sebastian. He has continued drinking, has become derelict, and attached himself to a monastery in Tunis.

Ch 5 Suddenly Lord Marchmain returns from Italy in a severely enfeebled condition to die in his ancestral home. There is discussion about who will inherit Brideshead. Lord Marchmain disapproves of Bridey’s middle-class fiancee Beryl, and leaves the stately home to Julia in his will. Marchmain on his death bed reverts to his original religious belief. Julia then tells Charles that she cannot marry him and they must separate for ever.

Epilogue

Ryder and his men are occupying the ground floor of Brideshead, where troops have been vandalising the building and the grounds. He learns that Julia and Cordelia have gone out to Palestine to help in the war effort.


Brideshead Revisited – principal characters
Charles Ryder the narrator, a young man who becomes a painter then a soldier
Lord Marchmain head of the Flyte family, living in Venetian exile
Lady Teresa Marchmain his wife, a devout Roman Catholic
Earl Brideshead ’Bridey’ the elder son, emotionally bankrupt
Sebastian Flyte the charming, troubled younger son who becomes a derelict and alcoholic
Julia Flyte the attractive but remote elder daughter
Cordelia Flyte the younger daughter who is a selfless and devout Catholic
Celia Ryder Charles’ vivacious but unfaithful wife
’Boy’ Mulcaster Celia’s brother, a ‘Hooray Henry’ at Oxford
Rex Mottram a Canadian arriviste who marries Julia then tolerates her affair with Charles
Anthony Blanche an aesthete and homosexual friend of Charles and Sebastian

© Roy Johnson 2018


More on Evelyn Waugh
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Evelyn Waugh Tagged With: English literature, Evelyn Waugh, Literary studies, The novel

Decline and Fall

March 24, 2018 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, study guide, commentary, web links

Decline and Fall (1928) was Evelyn Waugh’s first novel. It was very well received on first publication, and he followed it up with similar acerbic social satires in Vile Bodies (1930), A Handful of Dust (1934), and Scoop (1938). Waugh is probably best known for his later novel Brideshead Revisited (1945) which was the basis of a very successful television series. But Decline and Fall has the distinction of introducing what became a hallmark of Waugh’s style – the use of black comedy.

Decline and Fall


Decline and Fall – commentary

The novel is in the comic tradition of the naive young innocent who becomes the victim of ever increasing disasters. This is a theme that goes back to Voltaire’s Candide (1759). Paul Pennyfeather is an orphan who is punished for a misdemeanour he did not commit and is cast out into the world with virtually nothing.

He is the blameless victim of the Bollinger Club’s vandalism, then his guardian refuses to give him his rightful inheritance and expels him from home. All the people he then meets (with the exception of Peter Beste-Chetwynde) are frauds, liars, criminals, and social failures living in a world of deception, incompetence, and villany.

Dr Fagan, his employer, is a posturing academic fraud who runs a seedy private college (a ‘public school’) with no regard for the students education or welfare. Fagan has a ‘butler’ Philbrick who turns out to be a confidence trickster, and who is later arrested for fraud. The glamorous and wealthy Mrs Beste-Chetwynde might have poisoned her husband and lives off the earnings of prostitutes. The prison governor Sir Wilfred Lucas-Dockery is a naive penal reformist who is responsible for a prisoner being murdered.

Contemporary readers will have little difficulty in seeing this as a radically irreverent critique of what in the 1920s was politically correct. The targets for Waugh’s satire range from moral blindness to modernist architecture. But there are also some excruciating passages which reveal the astonishing levels of racism that were considered acceptable at that time.

Margot Beste-Chetwynde arrives at the school sports day accompanied by her black lover Sebastian ‘Chokey’ Chalmondley. The reactions of the other guests are voiced using expressions that seem quite shocking: ‘What price the coon?’, ‘I think it’s an insult bringing a nigger here’, and ‘to put it bluntly, they have uncontrollable passions … it’s just their nature. Animals, you know’.

These opinions might reflect the social blindness and narrow prejudices of the fictional characters in the scene, but Waugh also makes Sebastian himself a figure of fun. Whilst wishing to claim an appreciation of traditional English culture, he responds to most enquiries with the stock phrase ‘I sure am that’. He makes a perfectly articulate plea for tolerance and understanding, but it is difficult to escape the impression that Waugh to some extent shares the prejudices he is satirising. For a fuller discussion of this topic, see David Bradshaw’s excellent introduction to the Penguin Classics edition of Decline and Fall.

Black humour

In addition to the comically villanous characters, there are several instances of what we now call black humour scattered throuout the narrative. These often involve a certain amount of criminality or violence. Three years befor the story opens, the Bollinger Club dinner featured a caged fox that had been stoned to death with champagne bottles. At the school sports day, the young Lord Tangent is shot in the foot by the drunken Prendergast with his starting pistol. It is mentioned quite casually in a later chapter that his foot has been amputated.

Margot Beste-Chetwynde not only owns a chain of brothels in South America, she demolishes a listed Tudor building, to put in its place a monstrosity of plate glass, lifts, leather walls, and modernist furniture designed by a twenty-five year old ‘professor’ of foreign extraction. Moreover it is quite possible that she has poisoned her husband (with ground glass).

The governor of the first prison to which Paul is sent is a theoretical reformist who believes hardened criminals can be reformed by appealing to their ‘creative’ instincts. When a religious maniac reveals that he was formerly a cabinet-maker, the governor issues him with a set of carpenter’s tools – which he promptly uses to saw off a man’s head.

The scenes at the Llanabba College that feature locals are drenched in anti-Welsh sentiment. Waugh captures brilliantly the fractured syntax of the local stationmaster speaking in English, which for him is a foreign language:

‘To march about you would not like us? … We have a fine yellow flag look you that embroidered for us was in silks.’

The stationmaster divides his time between squeezing more money out of Dr Fagan and trying to sell his sister’s services as a prostitute at cut-price rates. Doctor Fagan then philosophises about the Welsh in general:

From the earliest times the Welsh have been looked upon as an unclean people. It is thus they have preserved their racial integrity. Their sons and daughters mate freely with the sheep but not with human kind except their blood relations … The Welsh are the only nation in the world that has produced no graphic or plastic art, no architecture, no drama. They just sing and blow down wind instruments of plated silver.

Waugh attributes these outrageous opinions to the foppish and incompetent Doctor Fagan, but once again it is difficult to escape the suspicion that he is hiding his own prejudices behind this literary strategy. When introducing the local brass band into the narrative he does so in third person mode that is just as insulting:

They advanced huddled together with the loping tread of wolves, peering about them furtively as they came, as though in constant terror of ambush; they slavered at their mouths, which hung loosely over their receding chins, while each clutched under his ape-like arm a burden of curious and unaccountable shape.

In fact the black humour and the comic potential of naively thwarted expectations are rather prescient of attitudes that only became more popularly widespread in Britain after the Second World War. Evelyn Waugh was well ahead of his time in this respect.


Decline and Fall – study resources

Decline and Fall – Penguin – Amazon UK

Decline and Fall – Penguin – Amazon US

Decline and Fall – York Notes – Amazon UK

Evelyn Waugh: A Life Revisited – Amazon UK

Decline and Fall – DVD film – Amazon UK

Decline and Fall

Evelyn Waugh – by Henry Lamb


Decline and Fall – plot synopsis

Prelude   Paul Pennyweather has his trousers removed by the Bollinger Club and is unjustly sent down from Oxford University for ‘indecent behaviour’.

Part One

I.   Paul is castigated by his guardian for this misadventure. He withholds Paul’s rightful inheritance and expels him from home. Paul secures a post as schoolmaster at a private college in Wales.

II.   Paul arrives at the inhospitable Llanabba Castle, where he meets Dr Fagan and his daughters. He is given as special subject something he knows nothing about.

III.   He meets student Peter Beste-Chetwynde and ex public school Captain Grimes, who regales him with stories of his failures. Grimes is engaged to the unappetising elder Fagan daughter.

IV.   Paul meets ex-clergyman Prendergast, who bores him with tales of his fundamental religious doubts.

V.   Paul tries to establish discipline with his form, and becomes popular. Doubts are cast about Philbrick.

VI.   Paul is offered £20 compensation from Oxford, thinks to refuse it on principle, but Grimes accepts it on his behalf. Paul will treat his colleagues to dinner with the money.

VII.   Dr Fagan makes grandiose arrangments for the sports day. The ‘butler’ Philbrick reveals his unsavoury (and imaginary) criminal connections to Paul, and reveals his intention to marry Diana Fagan.

VIII.   The sports events are a mis-managed farce. Prendergast, who is drunk, shoots a boy in the foot with his starting gun.

IX.   Mrs Margot Beste-Chetwyde arrives with her black lover Sebastian ‘Chokey’ Chalmondley. He is the object of virulent racist commentary from the guests.

X.   In the aftermath of the sports day, Paul has fallen for Mrs Beste-Chetwynde.

XI.   The butler Philbrick has given the staff various fantastic stories about his origins.

XII.   Dr Fagan disapproves of Grimes as a potential son-in-law. The staff go out to celebrate Grimes’ forthcoming marriage to the principal’s daughter. Grimes (who already has a wife) laments falling into the trap of matrimony.

XIII.   Grimes is depressed by his marriage, and resents being patronised by Dr Fagan. The police arrive to arrest Philbrick for fraud. Grimes stages his own disappearance.

Part Two

I.   Margot Beste-Chetwynde demolishes a historic Tudor building at King’s Thursday and has a modern replacement designed by young modernist ‘Professor’ Otto Silenus.

II.   In the Easter holidays Peter Beste-Chetwynde invites Paul back to his mother’s new house.

III.   There is a weekend party to show off Margot’s new modernist construction. She stays in bed, taking drugs. Paul proposes marriage to her, and he is accepted.

IV.   Grimes reappears, working for a Latin-American night club consortium owned by Margot.

V.   Margot is in London, interviewing hostess applicants for her Latin-American night club business (brothels).

VI.   Elaborate preparations are made for the wedding. Paul moves in to the Ritz. Paul’s friend Potts is working for the League of Nations. Paul goes to Marseilles to sort out visa problems for the hostesses. He returns to his much-publicised marriage day, but is arrested by the police.

Part Three

I.   Paul is sentenced to seven years imprisonment for white slave trafficking. At the trial Potts is chief witness for the prosecution. Margot flees to her villa in Corfu. The prison is run in a repressive and punitive manner. Paul meets Philbrick as a fellow prisoner and Prendergast is the prison chaplain.

II.   Paul wishes to remain in solitary confinement, which is against the rules, so the governor makes him the subject of a rehabilitation experiment.

III.   Paul exercises with a religious homicidal maniac, and complains to the governor. Since the man was formerly a cabinet maker, the governor issues him with a set of carpenter’s tools for ‘therapeutic rehabilitation’. The prisoner saws Prendergast’s head off.

IV.   Paul is transferred to Dartmoor prison, where he meets Grimes, who has been sent down for bigamy. Peter Beste-Chetwynde becomes an Earl. Margot visits to announce her forthcoming marriage to Miles Maltravers (son of the Home Secretary).

V.   Grimes escapes from Dartmoor but is thought to have perished in a mire. Paul thinks of him as inextinguishable.

VI.   The Home Secretary arranges for Paul’s removal to a nursing home owned by Dr Fagan. A fake death certificate is provided by a surgeon who is drunk. Paul is smuggled away to Margot’s villa in Corfu.

VII.   Paul recovers in Corfu, where he meets ‘Professor’ Silenus again. Paul returns to his old college at Oxford to study theology.

Epilogue   Peter Beste-Chetwynde, now Earl Pastmaster, visits Paul as an undergraduate at Oxford. Margot has married Maltravers and become Viscountess Metroland, with Alastair Digby-Vaine-Trumpington as her accepted lover.


Decline and Fall – principal characters
Paul Pennyweather a young student of theology
Dr Augustus Fagan foppish Llanabba Castle headmaster
Captain Grimes schoolmaster with wooden leg
Mr Prendergast ex-clergyman with a wig and religious doubts
Solomon Philbrick college ‘butler’ and fraudster
Professor Silenus a modernist architect (with no experience)
Margot Beste-Chetwynde rich and glamorous society woman
Peter Beste-Chetwynde Paul’s friend and student
Miles Maltravers marries Margot, and becomes Vicount Metroland
Alastair Digby-Vaine-Trumpington Margot’s lover

© Roy Johnson 2018


More on Evelyn Waugh
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Evelyn Waugh Tagged With: English literature, Evelyn Waugh, Literary studies, The novel

Men at Arms

March 18, 2018 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, study guide, commentary, web links

Men at Arms (1952) is the first volume of Evelyn Waugh’s trilogy Sword of Honour. The novels cover events in the second world war seen largely from the point of view of a willing volunteer – Guy Crouchback. He is eager to serve his country and has old-fashioned views on chivalry and the role of the English gentleman. The two later volumes are Officers and Gentlemen (1955) and Unconditional Surrender (1961). They can be read separately, but their significance is far greater when considered as a whole.

Men at Arms


Men at Arms – commentary

Guy Crouchback has the pressure of tradition and inheritance upon him. His family has a distinguished history and a country estate in the West Country (which is being used as a convent at the opening of the novel). His elder brother was killed on his first day of combat in the First World War. Another brother went mad and died. He has an elder sister, but under the conventions of primogeniture, neither she nor her offspring are eligible as inheritors of the family name and estate. Guy has been married but is now divorced and childless.

Moreover, as a practising Catholic, he believes he should not re-marry – which is why he embarks on the comic but painful episode in which he attempts to seduce his ex-wife Virginia in Claridges Hotel. Since the Catholic Church does not recognise divorce, she is the one woman with whom he can engage sexually without breaking any of the Church’s moral sanctions.

The planned seduction does not go well, and the promiscuous Virginia reproaches him in a particularly cruel manner. So – the continuity of the Crouchback ‘name’ via male inheritance rests firmly on Guy’s shoulders, but he feels there is very little he can do about it.

It is interesting to note that following a divorce which has clearly left him emotionally bruised, Guy is made happiest by what are essentially fourth form japes against the headmaster figure (Ritchie-Hook) in the episodes with Apthorpe’s ‘thunder box’. Guy tries to be honourable, but he is emotionally immature.

History of the text

Evelyn Waugh originally wrote and published the three volumes of the Sword of Honour trilogy as stand-alone novels. Men at Arms was published in 1952 , then followed by Officers and Gentlemen in 1955, and Unconditional Surrender in 1961. The separate volumes are united by the figure of Guy Crouchback, whose development and misadventures they trace.

But when the sequence was completed, Waugh edited the texts to make the trilogy a more coherent whole. The edits are fairly minor and do not change any significant episodes of the plot. For a detailed examination of the parallels and constructive differences, see the excellent introduction and explanatory notes to the Penguin edition of Sword of Honour edited by Angus Calder.

Even though the novels can be understood and enjoyed as separate fictional entities, it is clear that Waugh conceived of the trilogy as a whole. There are recurring characters about whom the reader only learns more fully when they appear in later volumes.

For instance, it is not made apparent in this first volume that the morally dubious character Trimmer is already known to Virginia, Guy’s ex-wife. We do not learn these details until the second volume of the trilogy when Trimmer is on leave in Glasgow and spends a few days with Virginia in a hotel. And it is not until the third volume that we learn Virginia bears Trimmer’s child, which Guy adopts as his own, following her death.

Humour

Waugh exploits both dramatic irony and elements of farce and black humour throughout the novel – and the trilogy. Even the titles of the three volumes are deeply ironic. The first, Men at Arms, is largely concerned with Guy’s failure to become engaged in a war for which he is a willing volunteer. He spends the majority of the novel in training and preparing for combat which does not materialise. The only military action he sees is a farcical (and completely unnecessary) night raid organised by his commander Ritchie-Hook, who emerges from the engagement with the severed head of an African guard as a trophy.

Similarly, the second volume, Officers and Gentlemen, is about the failure of the officer class (largely recruited from upper-class families) to show any proper leadership or competence. The third volume, Unconditional Surrender is about the ironic reversals of fortune that lead to Guy Crouchback’s compromise with his failed military and personal life.

Much of the humour is generated by the tension between Guy’s calm and stoical acceptance of all the trivial disciplines of military life and the comic efforts of his colleagues to avoid it. A prime example in Men at Arms is the episode of Apthorpe and his ‘thunder box’.

Apthorpe has bought a portable chemical toilet from a government official and wishes to reserve it for his private use. He hides it in various locations at their training camp, against the orders of their officer, the disciplinarian Ritchie-Hook, who pursues the matter with official notices banning access: Out of Bounds to all ranks below Brigadier.

Apthorpe clings to his possession for no other reason than a neurotic fear that he might contract veneral disease from the seat of a shared toilet. The conflict completely dominates Apthorpe’s existence, and the matter is not resolved until finally the brass-bound oak box is blown up in an explosion.

Guy supports Apthorpe’s efforts and remains loyal to him, whilst himself conforming to orthodox military discipline. When they are sent to Africa on a reconaissance expedition, Apthorpe contracts a tropical disease. Guy goes to comfort him in hospital, smuggling in a bottle of whisky against orders as a gift. Apthorpe finishes the bottle, and the alcohol kills him.

Guy thus emerges as something of a ‘holy fool’ character – the innocent who blunders into misfortunes. All his mistakes, large and small, are recorded in a confidential dossier that follows him round his various postings, and effectively prevents his being promoted.


Men at Arms – study resources

Men at Arms – Penguin – Amazon UK

Men at Arms – Penguin – Amazon US

The Sword of Honour trilogy – Paperback – Amazon UK

Sword of Honour – DVD film – Amazon UK
Channel 4 TV series adaptation – with Daniel Craig

Evelyn Waugh: A Life Revisited – Amazon UK

Men at Arms

Evelyn Waugh – by Henry Lamb


Men at Arms – plot summary

In 1939, shocked by news of the Hitler-Stalin pact, Guy Crouchback leaves his family’s second home in Italy to fight in the war. His brother-in-law Box-Binder discourages him, and he is unable to obtain a position. Guy’s father introduces him to Major Tickeridge, who recruits him to the Royal Corps of Halberdiers.

He undertakes officer training along with fellow recruit Apthorpe and the rather dubious Trimmer. At a Sunday lunch party he meets the bloodthirsty and eccentric Colonel Ritchie-Hook. Guy actually enjoys the routines and the companionship of the officer’s mess. On vacation in London he meets his selfish ex-wife and her second husband Tommy Blackhouse, from whom she is also divorced.

Guy’s unit is transferred to an uncomfortable former school on the coast. He makes an effort to be sociable, but still feels alienated. Guy and Apthorpe both join the local Yatch Club. The new brigadier Ritchie-Hook arrives and gives all the officers a dressing- down.

On leave Guy goes to London with the intention of seducing Virginia – but he finds her with Tommy Blackhouse, and Apthorpe keeps interrupting his efforts. Virginia rejects him scornfully anyway.

On return Ritchie-Hook has transformed their headquarters and established a new disciplined order. Apthorpe introduces his chemical toilet and begins a farcical episode of hide and seek with Ritchie-Hook. The ‘thunder-box’ is eventually destroyed in an explosion.

The brigade move to Scotland. Guy is not promoted in the new appointments, but Apthorpe becomes a captain, making him even more vainglorious and snobbish. There is petty competition for military superiority. The brigade is split up, with some personnel despatched to France. Guy’s group are reunited with Ritchie-Hook in Aldershot.

Preparations for transfer to France are shambolic. Guy’s unit muster for the anticipated invasion of Ireland by defending the Cornish coast. Ridiculous rumours flourish. They are eventually embark at Liverpool to sail for Dakar in French Senegal.

Ritchie-Hook is hoping for an attack on the Vichy French, but higher command calls it off. Instead, he organises an unofficial raid on the coast, led by Guy and his men, from which Ritchie-Hook returns with the severed head of an African guard.

The Halberdiers move on to Sierra Leone. Guy visits Apthorpe who is delirious with fever in hospital. He smuggles in a bottle of whisky – but this kills Apthorpe. Guy is dismissed from the Halberdiers and flown back to England along with the injured Ritchie-Hook.


Men at Arms – principal characters
Broome the Crouchback estate in Somerset
Guy Crouchback idealistic divorced Roman Catholic
Angela Box-Bender Guy’s sister
Arthur Box-Bender Angela’s husband, a Member of Parliament
Virginia Troy Guy’s louche ex-wife
Tommy Blackhouse Virginia’s second husband
Apthorpe Guy’s colleague in training
Colonel Ben Ritchie-Hook a reckless maverick warmonger
Ambrose Goodall a churchman with connections at Broome
Trimmer McTavish a womaniser, spiv, and ex-hairdresser

© Roy Johnson 2018


More on Evelyn Waugh
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Evelyn Waugh Tagged With: English literature, Evelyn Waugh, Literary studies, Men at Arms, The novel

Officers and Gentlemen

March 18, 2018 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, study guide, commentary, web links

Officers and Gentlemen (1955) is the second volume of Evelyn Waugh’s Second World War trilogy Sword of Honour. It follows Men at Arms (1952) and precedes the concluding volume, Unconditional Surrender (1961). The novels can be read separately, but their significance is far greater when considered as a whole. For a detailed examination of the parallels and constructive differences, see the excellent introduction and explanatory notes to the Penguin edition of Sword of Honour edited by Angus Calder.

Officers and Gentlemen


Officers and Gentlemen – commentary

The war

Waugh captures magnificently the chaos of war – the orders issued in ignorance, then immediately countermanded, the administrative departments at emnity with each other, and the assessments of ‘progress’ which are based on completely bogus information.

They had no transport, they had no cooks, they had far too many officers and sergeants, they wore a variety of uniforms and followed a multitude of conflicting regimental customs, they bore strange arms, daggers and toggle-ropes and tommy-guns.

More importantly Waugh exposes the reflection of the English class system into the armed forces. There is absurd concern with rank and petty deference to rules and regulations. There is suspicion and hostility between various parts of the military, the air force, and the navy. Officers educated on the playing fields of Eton behave as if they are dealing with teams from a rival college.

The ruling elite are concerned with who salutes whom; they conduct their social life with servants and batmen as if they were in gentlemen’s West End clubs; and they are largely ignorant of the organisational and technical details of the war they are fighting – and they are supposed to be leading.

The novel also emphasises the ironic contrast between appearance and reality. The officers are tasked to uphold honour, duty, and courage in the face of adversity. Instead they are shown evading responsibility and going to pieces.

Colonel Campbell is obssessed with explosives and finishes by blowing himself up. Major Fido Hound steals his own troops rations, loses his way and becomes delirious. Guy regards Ivor Claire as the embodiment of English chivalry – but Claire abandons his men and deserts his post when threatened by the German advance. He is posted to India to avoid possible Court Martial. And Guy is sent a long way back home so that he will not compromise this diplomatic move.

This is where Evelyn Waugh shows his main strengths. Although he is a conservative, with a sceptical view of progress, democracy, and egalitarianism, he exposes the weaknesses of the ruling class which he sees as failing and hopelessly ill-equipped to face the twentieth-century world.

The narrative

Waugh has a habit of making leaps in his narrative which leave certain important details unexplained. This may be the result of the trilogy being conceived as a whole, but written and published as a succession of separate novels.

We do not discover until this, the second novel in the trilogy, that Trimmer (a major character in the first volume) was once a hairdresser using the name ‘Gustave’. He worked on board the cross-Atlantic liner Aquitainia where one of his regular customers was Virginia (formerly Guy’s wife) travelling to meet her third husband Mr Troy.

Similarly, it is not at all clear from Officers and Gentlemen what happened to Major Hound in Crete and the survival boat skipper on their escape to Alexandria. These events are related mainly from Guy’s point of view, and we are given the impression that he became delirious and was then traumatised until his revival in the hospital at Alexandria.

But in the third volume of the trilogy, Unconditional Surrender, we are given the impression that Ludovic is terrified that Guy will reveal the truth about these disappearances when they meet at a party in Chelsea. The clear implication is that Ludovic has murdered Hound and thrown overboard the skipper of the boat on which they escaped.

It is somewhat ironic that the character of Ludovic was reputedly based on the real-life figure of the Ukranian-born Ludvick Hoch who fought with the British army during the war. He later took out British nationality and changed his name to Robert Maxwell before becoming a member of parliament and the head of a gigantic publishing empire. He was later revealed as a crook and an embezzler owing millions of pounds, who died in ‘mysterious circumstances’ by falling off his private yatch. An example, perhaps of Oscar Wilde’s dictum of ‘life imitating art’?

One of the other oddities of Waugh’s methods as a novelist is that he introduces standout characters who make serious appearances in the plot – only to be discarded or forgotten. The laird of Mugg and his crazed Nazi-supporting niece deliver memorable performances in the early part of the novel. Their macabre dinner at the Gothic and inhospitable castle is a comic masterpiece. Yet they never reappear and are written off later in a single sentence.

The great explosion which killed Mugg and his niece was attributed to enemy action.

It is quite clear that Ludovic has murky intentions: he has an arrogant attitude to his superiors; he keeps a secret diary; and he has a lofty and detached manner concerning the events in which he participates. Waugh suggests that ‘it is supposed’ that Ludovic threw overboard the sapper who was in control of the escape boat from Crete, but no reason is provided for such an action. In the third volume it is revealed that he is a Communist, and more surprisingly he writes a (bad) best-selling novel.

Waugh creates a convincing account of someone sliding into psychological collapse when Colonel Fido Hound becomes disoriented and lost in the retreat from Crete, but we do not really know what happens to him in the end. Waugh’s own notes to the novel claim that Ludovic might have killed Hound – but we are given no reason why this should be the case – except that Ludovic has earlier hinted menacingly that some officers were being shot by members of their own lower ranks. Yet Ludovic has earlier saved Colonel Hound when he was lost.


Officers and Gentlemen – study resources

Officers and Gentlemen – Penguin – Amazon UK

Officers and Gentlemen – Penguin – Amazon US

Sword of Honour – Paperback – Amazon UK
The full war trilogy – with explanatory notes

Sword of Honour – DVD film – Amazon UK
Channel 4 TV series adaptation – with Daniel Craig

Evelyn Waugh: A Life Revisited – Amazon UK

Officers and Gentlemen

Evelyn Waugh – by Henry Lamb


Officers and Gentlemen – plot summary

In 1940 Guy Crouchback returns from his posting in Africa to London and shelters from the Blitz in Bellamy’s Club. He reports next day for duty, but nobody expects him. His father old Mr Crouchback’s tenure at the seaside hotel is under threat because of petty regulations. Colonel Jumbo Trotter delivers Guy’s new orders and commandeers transport for the belongings of Apthorpe, who has died in Africa. Guy is posted to Scotland on ‘secret operations’ with X Commando.

On the Isle of Mugg Guy meets Trimmer McTavish and hands over Apthorpe’s gear. Guy goes with Tommy Blackhouse to a comically absurd dinner with the Laird of Mugg, who is obsessed with explosives and is rabidly Scottish. His niece is a mad supporter of Hitler against the British.

Trimmer goes to Glasgow on leave and picks up Virginia, Guy’s former wife. The laird shows Guy more of his explosives, and a ‘nutitionist’ doctor takes men on survivalist training expeditions. When the transport ship arrives for the unit’s mission there is great secrecy and confusion about their destination and objectives. Operation Hookforce sails to Cape Town, whilst Ritchie-Hook disappears on a flight to join them.

The operation travels on to Egypt without a commander, whilst moves are afoot in London to remove Hookforce as an irregular unit that is causing embarrassment. Guy lunches with the diplomat Stritch and his wife Julia in Alexandria.

In London, Trimmer is put in charge of Operation Popgun along with Ian Kilbannock as observer. He meets Virginia again, who is a friend of Ian’s wife. The Operation sails by submarine for an island in the Channel, but surfaces at the wrong destination on the German-occupied French coast. There is a botched attempt at demolition, but their sortie is reported a huge success. Trimmer is feted as a patriotic hero.

Guy and X Commando are despatched to assist at the evacuation of Crete, which is a grim shambles. Troops are in disarray and retreat; they are harrassed by the German Luftwaffe; and there is a complete lack of overall command.

Guy and Major Hound try to establish contact with someone in authority on the island. They are engulfed by soldiers in retreat. Hound becomes slightly delirious, gets lost, and is robbed by a Cretan partisan. He is rescued by Ludovic. Guy tries to join the retreating forces, but Hookforce has been ordered to remain covering the evacuation.

In London, Ian Kilbannock has problems trying to promote Trimmer, who has become obsessed with Virginia. On Crete, after a partial retreat, the remaining forces are ordered to surrender. But Guy and Ludovic manage to escape on a boat, hoping to be rescued.

Recovering in hospital, Guy is suffering from what today would be considered post-traumatic stress, until Julia Stritch arrives and takes him to recover in her house. She recounts Ivor Claire’s desertion of his troops in Crete and his ‘escape’ posting to India. Guy wishes to remain on active service, but is recalled to London.


Officers and Gentlemen – main characters
Guy Crouchback an idealistic and honourable young officer
Ian Kilbannock a former journalist
Tommy Blackhouse Guy’s friend and Virginia’s second husband
Colonel Jumbo Trotter an old Halberdier
Ivor Claire a dandy, horseman, and coward
Colonel Hector Campbell the laird of Mugg, a virulent Scot
Katie Carmichael his mad niece, a Nazi-supporter
Virginia Troy louche ex-wife to Guy and Tommy
Corporal-Major Ludovic a mysterious and dangerous character, and would-be writer
Julia Stritch glamorous wife of a diplomat in Alexandria
Trimmer McTavish a womaniser, spiv, and former hairdresser

© Roy Johnson 2018


More on Evelyn Waugh
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Evelyn Waugh Tagged With: English literature, Evelyn Waugh, Literary studies, The novel

Put Out More Flags

May 2, 2018 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, study guide, web links, plot summary

Put Out More Flags (1942) is the sixth novel by Evelyn Waugh. It deals with British society at the outbreak of war in 1939 and features characters who first appeared in his earlier novels Decline and Fall (1928), Vile Bodies (1930), and Black Mischief (1932). Most of the characters are drawn from upper-class society, but there are also satirical portraits from metropolitan Bohemia and the higher echelons of government and publishing. The story line is dominated by the outrageously unscrupulous character Basil Seal – a clever, womanising, ne’er-do-well.
Put Out More Flags


Put Out More Flags – commentary

This is something of a transitional work for Evelyn Waugh, containing much of the comic satire (and the characters) of his earlier novels, but at the same time it looks forward to the more serious elements of Brideshead Revisited (1945) and the Sword of Honour trilogy (1952-1961).

Whilst being largely a farcical comedy, it also contains interesting elements of well-observed social history – particularly the decline of the English upper class, the institutions of government, and ideological movements of the period in what we would now call ‘culture wars’.

Social history

The novel opens with Basil Seal’s sister, Barbara, trying to maintain a sense of normality in her two-hundred-year old country manor house. The servant class, on which her family’s privileged comforts have depended for generations, is melting away in the face of better employment prospects elsewhere. “Edith and Olive and me have talked it over and we want to go and make aeroplanes”.

For servants, the pay would be better working in a manufacturing industry, but they would also have more personal liberty and be free of the patronising and authoritarian discipline imposed by traditional upper-class employers. They would be free of the stifling deference required by the landed gentry who for generations had regarded themselves as superior beings.

This well-observed social development is also accompanied by a movement in the opposite direction – the arrival of evacuees from the larger cities. To protect children from the threats of bombing which were expected, it was government policy for them to be sent into the countryside. This social experiment had mixed results. Not all of the evacuees wanted to be there, and not all were suited to rural living. Waugh makes comic plunder of these issues in the scenes where Basil Seal acts as a bogus billeting officer.

Fashionable art

One of Evelyn Waugh’s favourite targets for satire in his early novels was contemporary fashions in the arts. In Decline and Fall the society Margot Beste-Chetwynde (later Lady Metroland) destroys a historic Tudor building to put in its place a monstrosity of plate glass, leather walls, and modernist furniture. In Put Out More Flags Waugh aims at the literary world. Much mention is made of the two proletarian poets Parsnip and Pimpernel.

They were great supporters of the republican cause during the Spanish Civil War, but as soon as Britain was under threat they emigrated to the United States. This is a satirical dig at Christopher Isherwood and W.H. Auden who did exactly that in 1939.

Poppet Green is a feather-brained ‘artist’ who follows whatever the latest fad happens to be – which in 1939 was surrealism. Her subjects are:

bodiless heads, green horses, and violet grass, seaweed, shells, and fungi, neatly executed, conventionally arranged in the manner of Dali. Her work in progress on the easel was an overlarge, accurate but buttercup-coloured head of the Aphrodite of Melos, poised against a background of bull’s-eyes and barley sugar.

She is also a communist – of a particularly simple-minded type. When her friend Ambrose Silk goes to work in the Ministry of Information, she immediately labels him a ‘fascist’ – and even worse, a Trotskyist. She thinks in slogans and labels: this is an accurate account of left wing orthodoxy at the time.

Characterisation

Ambrose Silk is a more subtle and nuanced example of fashion. He is a dandy and an aesthete who has been a communist sympathiser – a fellow traveller in the jargon of the time. Waugh pokes fun at him on two fronts. He is terrified of what might happen to him if the Germans invade Britain – since he is aware that the Nazis have persecuted left sympathisers. And more comically, he is writing a memoir Monument to a Spartan which describes his love for Hans, a German brown shirt fascist youth.

Ambrose eventually morphs into a slightly tragic figure – exiled in Ireland – which rescues him from being a two-dimensional character. The same is true of Angela Lyne, Basil’s ‘so-called’ lover. She is estranged from her husband the dilettante architect Cedric, and at the outset of the novel she is returning from the south of France where she has been fruitlessly waiting for Basil.

She closes her grand London home and moves into a top floor flat in Grosvenor Square. There, she gradually becomes a sad and lonely alcoholic. She maintains a veneer of respectability on her rare appearances in public – only ever drinking Vichy water. Alone, she slumps into an oblivion of vodka and Calvados cocktails. There are some truly touching scenes as this rich and fashionable society woman slowly degenerates and loses touch with reality.

So, amidst all the absurdity and tomfoolery in the rest of the novel, Waugh displays a mature touch as a writer in creating characters who change in time, who are not two-dimensional or vehicles for fun. Another example is Alastair Digby-Vaine Trumpington. He first appeared in the very opening scene of Decline and Fall, a Hooray Henry at Oxford, and he has lived a very conventional upper-class life ever since. Very rich, slightly naive, yet maintaining a ‘schoolboy’ sense of honour:

For him there was no ‘they’. England was at war; he, Alastair Trumpington was at war. It was not the business of any politician to tell him when or how he should fight. But he could not put this into words

And true to his principles, whilst the other characters are all trying to scuttle into cosy government sinecures or soft commissions as officers, Alastair volunteers to join the ranks. He endures the miseries of basic training without complaint (although he makes sure his wife Sonia has booked a comfortable nearby hotel for weekends). And in the end he is volunteering for Special Services – though it does seem to be the Boy’s Own Adventure prospects which appeal to him. But he is a character who develops, and he obviously represents what Waugh sees as the remaining strand of decency in upper-class values.


Put Out More Flags – study resources

Put Out More Flags – Penguin – Amazon UK

Put Out More Flags – Penguin – Amazon US

Six novels by Evelyn Waugh – Amazon UK

Evelyn Waugh: A Life Revisited – Amazon UK

Evelyn Waugh: The Height of his Powers – essay

Books of the Times: Put Out More Flags – essay

Put Out More Flags

Evelyn Waugh – by Henry Lamb


Put Out More Flags – plot summary

Chapter I.   At the outbreak of the Second World War Barbara Sothill’s country manor at Malfrey loses staff who prefer to work in factories. The estate is surrounded by evacuees from Birmingham. Lady Cynthia Seal asks her friend Sir Joseph Mainwaring to find a position for her wayward son. Angela Lyne returns in disappointment from the south of France, having been let down by her lover Basil Seal. In Fitzrovia, mixing with arty bohemians, Basil is living in a dissolute manner, and he bungles the army interview that is arranged for him.

Ambrose Silk visits the Ministry of Information where memos are exchanged regulating the display of personal effects in government offices. As an aesthete and a well-known left-wing sympathiser, he is concerned about his safety in the event of a German invasion. Basil is in the same building, promoting the idea of annexing Liberia.

Chapter II.   Basil goes to stay with his sister at Malfrey, where three delinquent evacuee children are forced onto them. Basil pretends to be a billeting officer and dumps the children onto a retired couple in their beautiful old home. When a few days later they are at their wits end, Basil charges the couple money to take the children elsewhere.

Alastair Trumpington endures the petty bureaucracy of life in the ranks. Ambrose Silk is working at the Ministry of Information, worried that even fellow-travellers might be at risk. Angela Lyne has shut down her home and is enduring a lonely existence in a Grosvenor Square flat. Alastair Trumpington is involved in absurd training exercises.

Chapter III.   Basil sells the three delinquent evacuee children to an adjacent billeting officer and returns to London. He bluffs his way into the War Office and is taken on as an intelligence agent by an old acquaintance. Lord Peter Pastmaster is trying out a girl with a view to marriage. They meet a bemused and drunk Angela Lyne at a cinema. Basil consoles her.

Cedric Lyne goes to see his estranged wife before his departure for Norway. Basil plans to reveal Poppet and Ambrose as communist sympathisers. Cedric is met by a shambolic embarkation of troops at the port.

Ambrose writes about his lost love for Hans, a German brown shirt youth in Mr Bentleys new magazine The Ivory Tower. Basil persuades Ambrose to change his memoir, making it more pro-German. He then reports him to the War Office as a Nazi sympathiser.

When warrants are issued for arrests Basil helps Ambrose escape to Ireland and takes over his Bloomsbury flat – to which he invites Susie, secretary to his boss. The police are only able to arrest Mr Rampole, the magazine publisher. Cedric Lyne is in a disoriented state on the battlefield and is killed in an attack.

Epilogue

Sir Joseph Mainwaring believes all the myths and rumours circulating about the war. Alastair is posted to coastal defence and wishes for more excitement. Rampole reads ‘light fiction’ in prison, and Basil joins a special service unit.


Put Out More Flags – main characters
Basil Seal a disinherited playboy, womaniser, and confidence man
Lady Cynthia Seal his widowed mother
Sir Joseph Mainwaring a government minister and confidant to Lady Seal
Barbara Sothill Basil’s sister
Mrs Angela Lyne Basil’s lover, daughter of a millionaire
Cedric Lyne her estranged husband, a dilettante architect
Ambrose Silk left-wing gay Jewish aesthete
Alastair Trumpington an aristocratic bohemian
Sonia Trumpington his wife
Poppet Green a surrealist painter and ‘communist’

© Roy Johnson 2018


More on Evelyn Waugh
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Evelyn Waugh Tagged With: English literature, Evelyn Waugh, Literary studies, The novel

Scoop

April 26, 2018 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, study guide, plot summary, web links

Scoop (1938) was Evelyn Waugh’s fifth published novel. It continues the comic themes he had established with Decline and Fall (1928), Vile Bodies (1930), Black Mischief (1932), and A Handful of Dust (1934). A naive and innocent young man is swept up into events which are beyond his control. He is surrounded by villainy and deception on all sides. Farcical misunderstandings abound, and the workings of the press come in for a great deal of satire.

Scoop


Scoop – commentary

There are three main targets for Evelyn Waugh’s satire in Scoop – African government, the English upper class, and the profession of journalism.

Like its predecessor Black Mischief, Scoop is largely set in a fictional African country – Ishmaelia. The government is run entirely on a system of nepotism: every official is a member of the same family. Voting is rigged, and ‘the adverse trade balance [is] rectified by an elastic system of bankruptcy law’.

When a quarrel breaks out in the ruling family (leading to civil war) one faction declares that the Ishmaelites are in fact a white race who must ‘purge themselves of the Negro taint’. A military coup takes place, the first result of which is a proclamation abolishing Sundays. The coup is overthrown the following day.

And although there is fun made of native incompetence in running the government, the naivety of its original colonisers is not forgotten:

Various courageous Europeans, in the seventies of the last century, came to Ishmaelia, or near it, furnished with suitable equipment of cuckoo clocks, phonographs, opera hats, draft-treaties and flags of the nations which they had been obliged to leave. They came as missionaries, ambassadors, tradesmen, prospectors, natural scientists. None returned. They were eaten, every one of them; some raw, others stewed and seasoned

Evelyn Waugh worked in journalism for Lord Beaverbrook’s Daily Express and made journeys to Africa and South America reporting for a number of newspapers. He had satirised the behaviour of journalists in earlier novels, but Scoop mocks the entire profession, from individual reporters to editors and even newspaper owners.

It is the lofty vanity of Lord Copper, owner of the Daily Beast that precipitates the misunderstanding about Boot’s identity in the first place. It also provides the toe-curlingly embarrassing finale when Copper is forced to address his celebration banquet with William Boot’s uncle Theodore, the aged roue, representing the ‘achievements of youth’.

Journalists and the upper class are combined as targets of his satire in a wonderful episode where the foreign editor Mr Salter is forced to visit William Boot at his home in the depths of the West Country. Beyond Taunton he is just as out of his depth as Boot has been in Africa. The family’s home at ‘Boot Magna’ is a parody of upper-class rural existence. It is remote, cold, and unwelcoming, offering superficial consideration with no human warmth. The accommodation is austere, and an extended family of quasi-eccentrics is characterised by each member locked into isolated self-interest.

But the main target for Waugh’s satire is journalists – particularly the English. They cluster together at the Hotel Liberty as if it were a gentleman’s club. None of them do anything active in the way of news gathering; they hardly ever venture outside the confines of the hotel bar; and their main source of information is each other. Yet they all want to claim the kudos for being the first to report important new events – hence the title of the novel.

William Boot is not unlike his historical counterpart Candide – a simple and naive young man confronted by the villany and absurdity that exists outside his sheltered world. He is living in peaceful rural seclusion, happy to be writing his articles on countryside matters. Because of the incompetence of other people he is pulled out of this simple and untroubled life and plunged into an almost farcical situation. He is surrounded by liars, cheats, and frauds; his gullibility is preyed upon by charlatans; and like many naive innocents he falls in love with an unscrupulous vamp.

Katchen is virtually a prostitute who squeezes money out of him at every possible opportunity. She claims to be married, but isn’t. She claims to be German, but is of mongrel Pan-European origin. William is well to be rid of her when she departs in his collapsible canoe.

And at the end of it all, just like Candide, William Boot is happy to simply return home and ‘cultivate his garden’. He eventually rejects the lure of Fleet Street and returns to the profound depths of the West Country and resumes his column Lush Places:

the wagons lumber in the lane under their golden glory of harvested sheaves, maternal rodents pilot their furry brood through the stubble


Scoop – study resources

Scoop – Penguin – Amazon UK

Scoop – Penguin – Amazon US

Scoop – study guide – Amazon UK

Six novels by Evelyn Waugh – Amazon UK

Evelyn Waugh: A Life Revisited – Amazon UK

Scoop – DVD film – Amazon UK

Put Out More Flags

Evelyn Waugh – by Henry Lamb


Scoop – plot summary

Book I – The Stitch Service

Socialite Mrs Stitch recommends novelist John Boot to Lord Copper of the Daily Beast to cover a political crisis in Ishmaelia. The newspaper’s foreign editor by mistake invites William Boot, who writes a countryside column for the newspaper. William is a naive and hopelessly inexperienced provincial young man.

He is nevertheless engaged and kitted out with ridiculously inappropriate equipment. After obtaining visas from rival consulates he flies to France and catches the train in Paris where he is joined by a dubious and boastful fellow passenger. On a ship from Marseilles he is harrassed by the crude agency journalist Corker who spies on Boot’s telegrams from the Beast and collects tourist junk from the bazaars.

Book II – Stones £20

Ishmaelia is a country theoretically organised on rational liberal principles but is actually dominated by a corrupt family and run incompetently. During a period of political turbulence, journalists from several countries are based at the Hotel Liberty.

When William Boot and Corker arrive their luggage has been lost in transit. The journalists desperately seek information from each other. One cables news of a new Bolshevik envoy simply because he has a false beard – but the man turns out to be a railway ticket collector.

Boot is given information by the British vice-consul, but Corker denies its validity. A special train arrives with their lost luggage and lots more journalists. Boot moves into a pension and meets a married German girl who immediately dupes him out of twenty pounds.

The journalists depart en masse into the interior to visit a city which does not exist. William stays in the capital and falls in love with Katchen, who is not married and is not German. He is sacked from the Beast but the same day sends them some gossip he has picked up from Katchen, who is fleecing him mercilessly.

The British envoy reveals to Boot the mining rights to gold mineral deposits that are the cause of political tensions. He relays this information to the Beast and is re-instated. Katchen’s ‘husband’ appears to recover his gold ore and Katchen herself. They escape in William’s collapsible canoe.

The mysterious Mr Baldwin arrives by parachute and gives Boot lots of detailed political information. The Soviet Union of Islamaelia is proclaimed. Its first act is to abolish Sundays. A counter-revolution occurrs on the same day.

Book III – Banquet

Lord Copper of the Beast recommends Boot for a knighthood – but it is awarded in error to the novelist John Boot, the author of smutty stories.

William returns to great acclaim but turns down public adulation and goes straight back home. Mr Slater is despatched to Boot Magna to sign William to the paper in fear that he will join the rival Daily Brute. Slater is poorly received and pestered by William’s garrulous uncle.

Lord Copper gives a banquet to honour William, but it is his aged uncle Theodore Boot who is mistakenly presented as the hero and commended as the ‘triumph of youth’.


Scoop – main characters
William Boot a young writer on rural matters
John Courtney Boot a remote cousin, writer of ‘smutty’ novels
Theodore Boot William’s elderly uncle, a roue
Lord Copper owner of the Daily Beast
Mr Salter obsequious foreign editor of the Beast
Mrs Stitch well connected society lady
Corker vulgar agency reporter
Katchen a mercenary blonde prostitute

© Roy Johnson 2018


More on Evelyn Waugh
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Evelyn Waugh Tagged With: English literature, Evelyn Waugh, Literary studies, The novel

The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold

April 24, 2018 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, commentary, plot summary, web links

The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold (1957) is something of a curiosity in the work of Evelyn Waugh. It is usually classed as a novel, but has more of the characteristics of a novella. Quite clearly it is autobiographical in origin, and in essence it has only one character – Gilbert Pinfold himself. In this sense it can also be regarded as a psychiatric case study – except that the condition it dramatises was eventually diagnosed as a pharmacological, not a psychological problem. It continues Waugh’s fictional strategy of combining serious problems with dramatic irony and comic misunderstandings.

The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold


The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold – commentary

Story – novel – novella

The publication could easily be classed as a long story. It deals essentially with one person’s experiences. It starts with the onset of his problems in a domestic English setting. It follows his escapist travels and the intensification of his psychic dramas. Then the narrative returns to its starting point and the solution to his problems. Pinfold is cured, and he decides to write the book we have just been reading.

None of the secondary characters have any real substance, and some of them do not even exist. In this sense it is simply a yarn or a tale whose principal interest is the depiction of a mental disorder from the sufferer’s point of view – and the comic consequences to which this breakdown leads.

To regard it as a novel raises problems. As an account of Pinfold’s psychological difficulties it lacks substance, since the majority of the drama is composed of imaginary events. After a perfectly credible opening, the story drifts into a dreamlike state which lacks the concrete reality that is normally part of a realistic novel.

More importantly, there is no acceptable explanation given for the resolution of the psycho-somatic tensions Pinfold is suffering. His physical pains suddenly and inexplicably disappear half way through the story, and the hallucinations evaporate just as suddenly when he reaches home. No reason is given for their origins or dissolution.

This might be the result of using personal experience as the material of what purports to be fiction. The events of the story are very closely based on Evelyn Waugh’s own ‘mid life crisis’ during which he undertook a sea voyage in an attempt to cure writer’s block. He also suffered from a form of persecution mania and delusions.

The cause of these problems was eventually identified as poisoning brought on by his heavy use of drugs and alcohol. As soon as his medication was changed, the hallucinations disappeared completely. There is no comparable resolution provided within the text. The story simply ends with the sort of ‘It had all been a dream’ conclusion to a schoolchild’s creative writing exercise.

But a stronger case can be made for considering it as a novella. It has unity of theme, unity of tone, and unity of character. It also has a neat triangular structure. The story begins with the origins of the drama in an English country house. Its central section deals with the development of Pinfold’s ailments during a sea voyage. And the problems are resolved on finally returning home.

This is simply an alternative view of the same literary material. It suggests a formal coherence in the events of the story, but it doesn’t provide the logical inevitability normally expected from narratives in the form of a novella. This essential element of formal resolution, unfortunately, is missing.


The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold – study resources

The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold – Penguin – Amazon UK

The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold – Penguin – Amazon US

Evelyn Waugh: A Life Revisited – Amazon UK

Four novels by Evelyn Waugh – Amazon UK

The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold – extensive Wikipedia entry

The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold

Evelyn Waugh – by Henry Lamb


The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold – plot summary

Gilbert Pinfold is a successful middle-aged author with conservative views and habits. He lives privately on an estate in what seems to be the West Country. He has problems sleeping, drinks heavily, and takes barbiturates. Following an unpleasant interview by the BBC, he finds his memory playing tricks.

He decides to go somewhere hot to finish his latest book. Despite being in ill health and unable to complete everyday tasks, he continues to drink heavily. On board ship he begins to lose track of time and starts having hallucinations. He loses social control at dinner, then overhears a riot on deck – which is severely quelled by the captain.

After lunch the next day he hears the trial and torture of a crew member coming from the captain’s cabin. The crewman dies. Following this, the pains in Pinfold’s legs suddenly disappear.

He hears a radio broadcast criticising his work as a novelist, then at the dinner table thinks to challenge the captain by raising the subject of murder. He stays awake to check that the captain does not dispose of the crewman’s body at night. Then he overhears two drunken youths who are threatening to beat him. The youths wake up other passengers, all of whom have criticisms of Pinfold.

Next morning Pinfold hears two girls planning to give him presents. The two loutish youths begin to taunt him again. They accuse him of being homosexual, a German (Peinfeld), a Jew, and a communist. Pinfold plans to bring them to trial in the ship’s lounge.

As the ship nears the Mediterranean, Pinfold learns that an international conflict has arisen over possession of Gibraltar. The captain reveals that the Spanish authorities want to capture a secret agent who is on board. He proposes giving them Pinfold as a substitute. When nothing happens Pinfold wonders if he is going mad, but decides it was all a hoax.

He becomes convinced that all the passengers on board are talking about him. A young girl called Margaret whom he has never met makes amorous overtures to him. Her parents intervene – but only to encourage her to visit Pinfold’s cabin at night. She is urged on by her father in military terms, but nothing happens.

When Pinfold overhears passengers laughing over telegrams he has sent he complains to Captain Steerforth and changes his cabin. He also thinks the practical jokes played on him have been orchestrated by Mr Angel, the man from the BBC who interviewed him.

He decides to thwart Angel’s plans by leaving the ship at Port Said and flying on to Colombo. He writes to his wife explaining the plot against him and signalling his intentions.

In Colombo he continues his conversations with Margaret. His wife sends a cable, urging him to come home. When he does return, the voices pursue him all the way back to London. He meets his wife and the voices stop. When they get home he decides to write The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold.

© Roy Johnson 2018


More on Evelyn Waugh
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Evelyn Waugh, The Novella Tagged With: English literature, Evelyn Waugh, Literary studies, The novel

Unconditional Surrender

March 18, 2018 by Roy Johnson

tutorial, study guide, commentary, web links

Unconditional Surrender (1961 is the third and final volume in Evelyn Waugh’s trilogy Sword of Honour following Men at Arms and Officers and Gentlemen. The events of the novel are very loosely based on Evelyn Waugh’s own experiences of his Second World War service between 1939 and 1945. For a detailed examination of the parallels and constructive differences, see the excellent introduction and explanatory notes to the Penguin edition of Sword of Honour edited by Angus Calder.

Unconditional Surrender


Unconditional Surrender – commentary

The principal themes

The final volume of the trilogy continues the main concerns of its two predecessors – the absurd bureaucracy and inefficiency of military organisation, and Guy Crouchback’s search for an honourable existence in a chivalric tradition which is collapsing all around him.

The contradictions of life in the armed services are all too obvious. There is snobbishness and petty discipline throughout the organisation, plus ridiculous distinctions in levels of superiority. Personnel are promoted for no reason other than administrative convenience, then just as arbitrarily demoted.

Supplies fail to arrive, then are delivered when there is no longer any need for them. Orders are issued, then cancelled with no explanation. Troops are put on alert for attacks which do not take place. Key roles are allocated to personnel with no appropriate skills or experience.

This is not merely Evelyn Waugh expressing some form of revenge criticism for the discomforts he may have suffered during his own military experience. Rather, he sees the whole officer class as blinded by its own ignorance and privilege. It is a patrician view of regret that some imaginary tradition of honourable conduct is coming to an end. And it is being replaced by a shabby and lacklustre modernity.

Guy Crouchback

The case of Guy Crouchback as an individual is very closely linked to that of official disarray and inefficiency in the officer class. Guy is trying to uphold the values and behaviours of an old chivalric tradition which is in terminal decline. In fact he is the last male member of the Crouchback family. His elder brother has been killed in the first world war (on his first day in combat) and his other brother has gone mad and died.

Guy has been married (to Virginia) but is now divorced and has no children. To emphasise the fact that he is the last chance for producing a hereditary heir to the Broome estate, his father dies during the course of Unconditional Surrender and Guy is described by a friend as fin de ligne.

All Guy’s attempts at making a positive contribution to the war effort come to nought – largely because of military incompetence, but also as a result of his ‘bad luck’ and outdated notions of honourable behaviour.

To emphasise Guy’s impotence, Waugh produces his final satirical piece of irony. Guy re-marries the feckless, selfish, and louche Virginia – a woman whom he desires but does not really love. And she is pregnant with someone else’s child. In fact Guy re-marries her because she is pregnant: he takes on the unborn child as a chivalrous gesture to help a woman in distress.

More than that, the ‘someone else’ is Trimmer McTavish, the lower-class opportunist and womaniser who is the moral epitome of everything Guy disdains and tries to rise above. So the Crouchback line and tradition appears to be continued as far as the public is concerned, but Guy knows that it is not. At the end of the novel, following the death of Virginia in a doodle bug raid, Guy gets married again to a younger woman – but they have no natural children between them.

And to further underscore this theme of decline in the upper-class and its traditions, there is a similar ‘end of the line’ conclusion in the other branch of the family. Guy’s sister Angela has a son, Tony, who joins the army at the same time as Guy. Tony is taken prisoner during the war, but at its end he takes up holy orders and enters a monastery. There is to be no continuity on that side of the Crouchback family either.

Conclusion

The novel ends with a series of misunderstandings and ironic reversals that accurately mirror those of its beginning. Guy befriends and tries to help a group of Jews who are being treated as ‘displaced persons’. As a parting gesture he gives one family his remaining rations and a pile of old American magazines. The family are arrested by partisans and tried as spies possessing ‘counter-revolutionary propaganda’. The implication is that they are executed. Guy’s act of good will brings about the death of people he has tried to help – just as his friendly bottle of whisky killed Apthorpe.

Ludovic the strange author of pensees is revealed as someone mentally unstable, a murderer, and a Communist. He also rather surprisingly turns out to be the best-selling author of The Death Wish which seems to be a bad romantic novel. His royalty proceeds are spent buying Guy’s family home in Italy.

Sir Ralph Brompton is almost like a character from the Cambridge Spy Ring: he co-ordinates the activities of the other communists and their sympathisers whilst appearing to be an unimpeachable member of English society.

After his escape to India to evade a court matial for cowardice in deserting his troops in Crete, Ivor Claire joins the Chindits in Burma and is awarded a Distinguished Service Order.

In other words, treachery and bungling incompetence are rewarded, whilst honourable, chivalrous behaviour results in ironic tragedy. It is not surprising that Guy Crouchback finally retreats into cultivating his garden.


Unconditional Surrender – study resources

Unconditional Surrender – Penguin – Amazon UK

Unconditional Surrender – Penguin – Amazon US

Sword of Honour – Paperback – Amazon UK
The full trilogy – with explanatory notes

Sword of Honour – DVD film – Amazon UK
Channel 4 TV series adaptation – with Daniel Craig

Evelyn Waugh: A Life Revisited – Amazon UK

Unconditional Surrender

Evelyn Waugh – by Henry Lamb


Unconditional Surrender – plot summary

Eight weeks after leaving Alexandria Guy arrives back in London. Trimmer is touring northern England as a war hero accompanied by Virginia. No proper job can be found for Guy, and he is too old for active service. He is given an ill-defined job as a liaison officer, with very little to do.

Ludovic has had his pensees accepted for publication by a left-wing magazine. Virginia is divorced by her third husband Mr Troy. She is tired of Trimmer, pregnant with his child, and broke. When Ludovic meets Guy at a smart party in Chelsea, he is frightened that Guy will reveal the truth about what happened during the retreat from Crete. There is an implication that he was responsible for the deaths of Horn and the boat skipper.

Old Mr Crouchback dies, leaving Guy the last in his family’s line, but inheriting half of the money. Guy wonders if some task or duty will arise to assuage his sense of ennui and uselessness.

Virginia tries to locate an abortionist, without success. Ludovic is in charge of parachute training, to which Guy is sent prior to a posting in Italy. In fear of being recognised, Ludovic hides from everyone. Guy injures his knee on the practice jump and is hospitalised. Ludovic nevertheless recommends him for active service – in order to get rid of him.

Guy goes to stay with his bachelor uncle Peregrine. He is visited by Virginia, who flirts with Peregrine and wants to re-marry Guy. She tells him about her pregnancy, and he marries her because of it, out of a sense of chivalry and self-sacrifice.

Guy arrives in Bari in southern Italy and is briefed for a posting in Yugoslavia. He is put in charge of a supply airfield in Croatia and becomes caught up in problems dealing with a group of Jews who are being treated as displaced persons.

In London Virginia converts to Catholicism, has her baby, and then ignores it. Ludovic completes a long romantic novel. Guy is joined by his new commander Frank de Souza, and he learns of the death of Virginia and Peregrine in a flying bomb attack.

A bogus military operation is mounted for the sake of visiting dignitaries, including Ritchie-Hook who returns to the story. The aeroplane bringing them from Italy crashes on arrival, killing several of the crew. The staged attack on an enemy post is badly organised and executed, and Ritchie-Hook (acting alone) is killed.

Guy’s attempt to save a group of Jews fails, and he is recalled to Italy. He learns later that their leaders have been betrayed by information supplied by Communists from within his own ranks.

In 1951 after the war Guy marries the daughter of the woman who has raised Trimmer’s son, and he becomes a farmer in Somerset. Ludovic buys Guy’s family home in Italy on the strength of his royalties.


Unconditional Surrender – main characters
Guy Crouchback an idealistic and honourable young officer
Ian Kilbannock a former journalist
Tommy Blackhouse Guy’s friend and Virginia’s second husband
Colonel Jumbo Trotter an old Halberdier
Virginia Troy ex-wife to Guy and Tommy
Corporal-Major Ludovic
Julia Stritch glamorous wife of a diplomat in Alexandria
Trimmer McTavish a womaniser, spiv, and former hairdresser
Sir Ralph Brompton diplomatic ‘advisor’ and Communist spy
Everard Spruce editor of Survival magazine
Lieutenant Padfield American liaison officer, former lawyer
Peregrine Crouchback Guy’s bachelor uncle, a bibliophile
Frank de Souza Guy’s witty friend, a Jewish Communist
Virginia Troy louche ex-wife to Guy and Tommy
Ivor Claire a dandy, horseman, and coward

© Roy Johnson 2018


More on Evelyn Waugh
More on the novella
More on literary studies
More on short stories


Filed Under: Evelyn Waugh Tagged With: English literature, Evelyn Waugh, Literary studies, The novel

  • 1
  • 2
  • Next Page »

Get in touch

info@mantex.co.uk

Content © Mantex 2016
  • About Us
  • Advertising
  • Clients
  • Contact
  • FAQ
  • Links
  • Services
  • Reviews
  • Sitemap
  • T & C’s
  • Testimonials
  • Privacy

Copyright © 2025 · Mantex

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in